Wednesday, January 23, 2013

The Constitution's been canceled in The Mill

I just finished Stephen King's Under the Dome and man. That was a long and stressful journey.

I don't really mean to read so much King. It just sort of happens, usually because I find copies of his books on sale and go "why not". Besides, if I ever want a book that's going to suck me in, King is a good way to go. And he's written roughly 2 bazillion novels so there is a LOT to choose from. And Laura was kind enough to put together a list of King books I should read based on his other stuff that I like.

The plot itself is very simple: one day a dome of some sort closes off the Maine (of course) town of Chester Mill from the rest of the world. No one knows what the dome is or where it came from but you can't get out and nothing can get in. And IMMEDIATELY shit starts to go wrong. Sort of Lord of the Flies mixed with a little An Inconvenient Truth.

There are a TON of characters to keep track of. I really should have made a chart. Except the chart would have to have been constantly revised. But there weren't so many characters that I couldn't follow or didn't enjoy it. I liked having so many characters to watch and it really made sense when you consider it was an entire town of around 2,000 people trapped together. Some are more directly involved with the action but everyone in town is affected in some way.

Big Jim Rennie is one of the best villains I can think of. He's intelligence, conniving, power-obsessed, narcissistic asshole. Every time he's around you know something bad is going to happen and the way he is able to manipulate people is disgusting and a bit impressive. The hero characters (Dale "Barbie" Barbara, Julia Shumway, Eric "Rusty" Everett) are all good and interesting people but it's not the same. There isn't really a lot of grey area with the characters. Sure, not all of them are as evil as big Jim, but for the most part all of the characters fall into one camp or the other. Which is fine and works with this story.

I said the story is long and stressful, and it is. It's 1,092 pages, at least according to Goodreads. I read the thing on my Kindle so I'm not exactly sure how long it is, other than I'm really glad I was reading a digital copy instead of a physical one. And it's stressful because OMG there is so much that happens to our poor characters. And just when you think nothing else awful can happen to them you realize you have nother 500 pages to go and your heart sinks a little because you know things are just going to get worse before they can (hopefully? maybe? please?) start to get better.

Here's my only problem with Under the Dome. I love the premise that there's this town completely cut off from everything but this dome. I love watching how the citizens react and how things start going downhill real fast. What I was less interested in was the dome itself and why it's there. And that's the problem. You can't just plunk down this dome and then have no explanation for it. That sucks. But if you DO explain it, then you spend time with the characters dealing with that instead of the craziness going on with the other people, and then I start to lose interest. I can't think of a way that this could have been remedied and still keep the dome so whomp.

TL;DR? Good, but not GREAT King with excellent build up but a bit of a let down ending.

There is apparently to be a TV mini-series adaptation of the book coming out this summer (so sayeth Wikipedia). If so I'll need to make sure to catch it. I know King adaptations can go very badly, but I still like to give them a try. Plus I liked the mini-series adaptation of The Shining so maybe that's the way to go with his stuff.

Title quote from location 3440

King, Stephen. Under the Dome. Scribner, 2009. Kindle edition.

Comments (30)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
"And just when you think nothing else awful can happen to them you realize you have another 500 pages to go "

That's how I felt during season 2 of The L Word (there're six seasons).

Yeeah, this is too long. But maybe someday you will have read ALL of Stephen King. And surely that's some sort of braggable achievement.
3 replies · active 638 weeks ago
I read this one a couple years back, wasn't a big fan of it. I didn't really like the characters and I thought the villainy was overwrought. Also, it was just too darn long! (And that's coming from someone who's favorite King is either The Stand or The Waste Lands.)

Sum-up line from my review: "You could make the case that most any small town has its secret megalomaniacs, but the worst-case scenario explored here is less interesting to me than the idea of normally sane, kind people going off the deep end, which I felt wasn't explored enough. "
1 reply · active 638 weeks ago
I need to read more King! By the sound of your review, I won't run out to get this one, but I want more King and I want it soon.
1 reply · active 638 weeks ago
I read Under the Dome last semester and I really liked the idea of it and I got really attached the the characters. I was rooting for the good guys like Barbie and Julia, and I hated (in a good way) Big Jim and his creepy son, but I thought that the explanation for the story was really weird. I know that it's Stephen King and it's sci-fi, but *SPOILER* kid aliens? Really? I was hoping that it was someone within the dome doing this intentionally because then it would still cause conflict between characters, which I thought was the best part of the novel. Also, it was sooooo long. Why did it have to be over 1000 pages long?

But I think I will check out the mini-series coming out in the summer out of curiousity. It might be really good.
~Sara
1 reply · active 638 weeks ago
This book had a great premise but failed for me on a few levels. The violence was a little too violent -- King's at his best when he's being subtle and this book wasn't that. I completely agree with you about the "why" of the Dome really being the weak point in this book.
1 reply · active 638 weeks ago
****SPOILERS****
I really enjoyed Under the Dome for the most part. I coincidentally read it at the same time as a co-worker, so it was nice to have someone to talk to about all the craziness that happens.

I did not like the aliens. Please, he couldn't come up with a better reason? I was thinking government experiment gone wrong or that we'd never know where it came from. The only redeeming quality was the connection to Julia's own childhood experiences.

I also didn't like how almost everyone died. The whole town minus a handful of people. I got so invested and hopeful for these characters, then poof.
6 replies · active 638 weeks ago
I have yet to read any King, though 11 22 63 is up there on my to-read list.

This plot reminds me a little of Blindness by Jose Saramago. A bunch of people suddenly trapped together with no outside forces to impose any sort of order or law? Yeah. Bad shit is gonna happen. The violence in that was hard to take; not sure I could take it on a Stephen King level...
1 reply · active 638 weeks ago
I have just started reading some of King's books. I really enjoyed the novellas in Different Seasons and I thought The Stand was fantastic. I'm reading The Shining and 11/22/63 next, but I'd love to hear what other books made it on the list your friend made for you!
2 replies · active 638 weeks ago
DID I TELL YOU YOU WERE ALLOWED TO READ THIS ONE THOUGH?! I suspect I did not, for I haven't read it yet. DAMMIT ALLEY!

For reals though, I really really want to read this, just so in my review I can go 'well, I guess SOMEONE saw The Simpsons Movie' because OMG how is the dome not stolen from that movie? It totally is.

ANYWAY you have not put me off this, so nice work! I am more looking forward to 11/22/63, BUT still, this sounds like it might be good, so YAY :)
1 reply · active 638 weeks ago
I really liked this one - but then he messed up the ending in such a big way that it completely ruined the rest of the book for me, unfortunately. I'd much rather retread The Stand once more than read this again...
2 replies · active 635 weeks ago

Post a new comment

Comments by