Friday, January 11, 2013

Harry - yer a wizard

It's time for the first Harry Potter readalong post about the book (as opposed to the intro post which is like the foreward to the whole readalong). THE EXCITEMENT
Photobucket
We're beginning this with the first 9 chapters of Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone (or Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone if you're not American and therefore, you don't get babied. Because apparently we are too stupid for any book that has "Philosopher" in the title.) And warning for everyone, there will be spoilers. And not just for those first 9 chapters. The whole series is fair game, though I'll try to only bring up spoilers when it's actually necessary for whatever ridiculous argument I'm trying to make. But this will mostly be made up of random thoughts.

I love the opening sentence. "Mr. and Mrs. Dursley, of number four, Privet drive, were proud to say they were perfectly normal, thank you very much." It's the "thank you very much" that does it. You can tell from that one sentence the stick up their collective ass is huge.

I don't so much mind the exposition dump when Dumbledore and McGonagall are waiting for Hagrid to show up with Harry. I have much more of a problem with the fact that Dumbledore's device is called "the Put-Outer". That sounds like the name you give something as a stand-in while you come up with something better. Come on now, Rowling.
Photobucket
The beginning spends a lot more time with the Dursleys than I remembered. But then again, I mostly remember the Dursleys as those few pages that happen at the beginning of the book before we get to Hogwarts and the magic. But that's cool cos I like those chapters. You gotta see how awful things are for Harry at home so he can be so excited and not-at-all homesick while at Hogwarts. Besides, I like the scene in the zoo with the snake. Although, how exactly was the snake planning on getting to Brazil? It's a bit of a ways away from England. I fear things don't end so happily for the snake.

It seems like the only place for you to buy all of your Hogwarts supplies is at Diagon Alley. Does that mean all of those stores have a monopoly on spellbooks and wands and cauldrons? That said
Photobucket
I love the scene at platform 9 3/4. Mostly because we get to meet the Weasleys and let's just admit that Mrs. Weasley is one of the best characters (and we can discuss how terrible the twins are later). Except I don't understand. Why doesn't the letter tell you how to get to platform 9 3/4? We've established kids born to Muggles get these letters so why should we assume they know what they're doing.

Why is Ravenclaw's mascot an eagle? Not a raven? No? Is there a clever reason behind that?

Man, Hermione is insufferable early on. I mean, more than normal 11 year olds. I don't like her not being friends with Ron and Harry, but I'm actually more surprised they all ended up besties. It just goes to show how awesome she is that her good qualities out weigh her know-it-all-ness. But I mean, someone has to have all of the answers throughout the series.

Here's something that randomly bugs me about the series, even though it's totally just me thinking WAY TOO HARD into this series and I should really just accept that it's a children's series. So the Dursleys HATE Harry and treat him like dirt and make him sleep under the stairs with the spiders. They've been his guardians since he was 1. And yet Harry is amazingly well adjusted. I keep thinking "Harry, wouldn't you be more of a sociopath? How are you able to form bonds with people if you had been completely neglected through your formative years? Rowling, why haven't you done extensive research into childhood psychology to answer these questions?" I know. I need help.

I was going to find my Hogwarts house by going through Pottermore and I made the username and everything and now it's telling me I need to go through chapters before I can get sorted. So what I'm saying is I haven't been sorted yet. Perhaps before the end of this readalong I'll get my house figured out. But I have really important places to be in the meantime
Photobucket


Title quote from page 50

Rowling, J.K. Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone. Scholastic, 1997.

Comments (44)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
It's definitely the "thank you very much" that makes that sentence so perfect. That + McGonagall being a strict looking cat, Hagrid's pink umbrella/wand and Dumbledore's sherbet lemon are just perfect character cues.

I think you can buy stuff at Hogsmeade and maybe even wizard towns like Godric's Hollow but everyone likes an outing right?
2 replies · active 640 weeks ago
DARIA.

Also I have a GIF about the Ravenclaw thing. ALSO, yeah, there's no way the snake actually made it out of there. But it 's nice that it got to have a fleeting thought of freedom.

The only thing that actually bugged me this time around was McGonagall being annoyed that Dumbledore recognized her as a cat. Don't Animagi always look the same? So it's not like he wouldn't have seen her as a cat before. I don't know.
1 reply · active 640 weeks ago
I love the opening sentence! And... y'know, every other sentence. I'm easy like that.

I read SOMEWHERE that there is a THEORY that the snake Harry helps at the zoo in book 1 turns out to be Nagini? I can't remember WHERE or HOW this fact fell into my life, except that it MAY have been on a nerd-board on Pinterest. It's one of those ideas that kind of makes you shiver a bit and go 'ooooh' even as you're thinking how highly unlikely it would be.

Roll on Post the Second - I was hoping to get stuck into the HP books again this week but Jane Eyre is MUCH longer than I remembered so I've been delayed a bit... I'm relying on you lot for my Potter fix until then! :)
1 reply · active 640 weeks ago
The boa couldn't have been Nagini. not large enough or poisonous enough. that's just amateur talk over on Pinterest. Just sayin'

You're so right about the character cues we get from rowling. when she's on, she's SO on when it comes to sketching character in a way that feels 3-d.

re: Harry and his lack of sociopathness? Yeah, that's a big sticker in my craw. i think the only thing we can deduce is that his mother's protective love is part of his human and magical signature and that he's a vessel to suck up and hold all the love he can manage once he's around non-abusers.
8 replies · active 640 weeks ago
Oh man this readalong is great. I love the idea that Lily's love protected Harry from becoming a sociopath. Nice one, Emily. And agreed that the boa couldn't have been Nagini, though I had heard that theory, too. Isn't Nagini described as a python?

I think you can buy school supplies at other places, it's just Diagon Alley has it all together in a row. Where elsewhere maybe you have to hunt around and junk. It's a wizard strip mall.
2 replies · active 640 weeks ago
I totally thought about Harry's complete well adjustedness. It reaaaally doesn't gel with the like 'oh, my guardians are so awful to me and no one at school likes me' it's like... he wouldn't even know how to TALK to other people. But I am SO down with Lily's love protecting him. That's just awesome.

And YES the put-outer is the lamest name for a thing EVER! Definitely should have gone back and changed that one, JK!

I don't know what to tell you about Diagon Alley. Only that it seems there are parts of the wizarding world that we don't know about at all, and that I guess we only see a really small section of it. OR it's really tiny. Either way.
1 reply · active 640 weeks ago
Ugh, the process to get sorted on Pottermore is so annoying and it's impossible to figure out what to do and I hated it. But I eventually got sorted.

And you're so right about the Put-Outer and not just I-agree-with-you right, but so-do-Rowling right, since she renames the thing before giving it to Ron (I can't remember what right now). They do say in book 6 or 7 that there are other wand-makers, so maybe there are indy bookstores too? I never thought about it before but you're right, why is Harry so normal? Shouldn't he cower and flinch and hoard chicken legs and chips in his school bag?
5 replies · active 640 weeks ago
Yes! Hermione is the snottiest, and also not even that important-seeming this early on. But we know better. (So doe she, of course. Know it all.)
1 reply · active 640 weeks ago
You know what really bugs me about the 9 3/4 scene? When the Weasleys walk by and Harry hears Mrs. Weasley ask, "What platform was it again?" (or something to that effect.) She has SEVEN CHILDREN, five of whom have already gone off to school, and she went to Hogwarts herself! I'm pretty sure she knows the name of the ONLY WIZARDING PLATFORM IN EXISTENCE.

Okay, I'm glad I got that out of my system. I'm taking this whole thing very seriously.
1 reply · active 640 weeks ago
I don't know, I think kids are more resiliant (I feel like I spelled that wrong but I'm too lazy to check) than we give them credit for. He's still fed and clothed and whatnot, however crappily, and it doesn't seem like they beat him or force him to break his back doing ALL the housework. And since he grew up with it, he doesn't know anything different. (Matilda is also a super-nice kid with a shitty family, now that I think about it.)

And YES Put-Outer is a stupid, awkward name. And those chapters in Pottermore took FOR-EV-ER and maybe it's just my computer but the site seemed really slow and annoying. I don't think there's a chance I'll get hooked on it.
1 reply · active 640 weeks ago
The snake reminded me of Alfred the Turtle. Yes to Hermione being insufferable. She's so annoying right now. And YES to the whole sociopath theory! Maybe he's not affected by it because he's a wizard?? So his brain is hardwired to get him through years of suffering? Why didn't anyone check up on him in 10 YEARS?? And why didn't Dumbledore just have some wizards raise Harry? Because then there would be no story, I know, BUT STILL. I get what you're saying.
4 replies · active 640 weeks ago
You know, I keep forgetting that Harry goes back with the Dursleys every summer. How AWKWARD. It's like making a sweeping exit and then having to go back because you forgot your purse.

And YES that snake and his lofty plans to go to Brazil. I believe in you, Snake...but I'm a little concerned that you maybe don't know your geography so well. And I hope you can swim.

SO MANY good points, madam. BRAVO.
1 reply · active 640 weeks ago
Just forced my wife to read this, and then The Hobbit, over the Holidays (she's usually not a fan of anything sff), and now I'm about to start it (again) so that we can have debates/arguments about it. I'll try to follow along!
1 reply · active 640 weeks ago
Ugh, the "put-outer" bugged me too, maybe Rowling was trying to ease us into all the magical sounding terminology until Diagon Alley and then WHOA, sensory overload. As for Diagon Alley, I guess since the wizarding world is so small and intimate, there would be a monopoly, but I imagined multiple bookstore, alternative apothecaries and suppliers, etc.
I'm surprised that Harry's so well adjusted - for a cupboard kid, he's got a cool head on his shoulders.
1 reply · active 640 weeks ago

Post a new comment

Comments by