Friday, January 25, 2013

Harry Potter must not go back to Hogwarts

It's Friday again so it's time for another Harry Potter readalong post! HUZZAH. As with all of these posts, there will be spoilers so reader beware.

So this week we finished up the first half of Chamber of Secrets which, full disclosure, is probably my least favorite of the series. It's certainly the one I forget about the most AND the one that didn't interest me enough to keep reading the series. I'm glad my friend convinced me to read the third book because I would have been happy stopping the series after this one.

I was very plot-hole-pokey with my Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone posts, so I'm going to try and not do that so much this time.
Photobucket
Even though, I would like to stress, that the plot holes did not diminish my love for the series. I really only noticed them because I love the series and therefore have spent waaaay too much time thinking these things over. It's probably not healthy.

This does not mean I'm going to be able to put together a coherent post. This is still going to be a bunch of random thoughts. But they'll just be more positive.

Any book in a series that isn't the first is going to have a bit of "Last time on..." and Chamber of Secrets is no exception. I hate these parts. I mean, I get they're necessary and I don't think it's bad that we get a little recap of what happened before, but I just finished SS and don't need a recap on the rules of Quidditch. Therefore, there was a bit of skimming through the first half.

Gilderoy Lockhart is such a wonderful character. I mean no one I'd actually like to deal with but man is it fun to watch him turn every conversation over to himself. Even though I read the book before I saw the movie, I still can't help but picture Kenneth Branagh in the role. Way to be an egotistical oblivious ass. And I mean that with love.
Photobucket
Cos come on, Harry's detention with Lockhart answering fan mail? Genius. Also nice to see that Hogwarts figured out that sending children into the Forbidden Forest is a bad idea. Especially when you consider flying a car to Hogwarts is a WAY worse offense than being out after dark.

I'm a little confused about Ron's wand breaking. Not how it broke or why it's malfunctioning, but how do you get a new one? I mean, he needs to get a new one, right? But getting a wand seems like such a big deal and "the wand chooses you" and all that jazz. So isn't it a big deal when you get a wand? And doesn't that mean you can't just replace it with any other wand?

Given Filch's reaction to seeing Harry read his Kwikspell letter, I get the feeling that being a non-magical person in the magical world is almost worse than Harry being a wizard while living with the Dursleys. Alright, no the Dursleys are worse, but still pretty awful. And very condescending.

On top of the squib thing, I feel so bad for Filch. His poor cat, Mrs. Norris. Side question, why Mrs. Norris? Did Filch have a kitty wedding at some point? Where's Mr. Norris? Is Mrs. Norris a widow? And now I feel bad for Filch for another reason. Poor guy.
UPDATE: From Alice, Mrs. Norris is named after a character in Mansfield Park. Though I have an easier time believing she's a widow cat than I do Filch is an Austen fan.

Can't wait for part two. And more than that, I can't wait until we're finished with this book and can move onto the next. Cos out of all of them, this is my least favorite HP. Whomp.

I'm not sure how to end this post so, Alley out!*
Photobucket
*Please be prepared to see this gif again. There is a good chance I am going to use this as the ending to all of these HP posts. Because I love Adam Scott so.

Title quote from page 19

Rowling, JK. Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. Scholastic, 1999.

Comments (45)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I ADDRESSED THE MRS NORRIS THING IF YOU ACTUALLY READ MY POSTS, ALLEY

(p.s. I love you)

No, um, she's named after a character in Mansfield Park. Named Mrs. Norris. Who is the WORST.

Also, I think with wands it's like, 'ok you CAN use someone else's, but it's just not gonna work as well for you, y'know?' And Ron probs couldn't afford a new one, so he's gotta make do until he can get a new one that fits him.
3 replies · active 638 weeks ago
Ahaha. You're last line is hilarious. I wish I could have done this with you guys! My favorite is the 4th, but I do think I had similar thoughts on this title. The bf recently got me the special edition collection or something, it like comes in a chest and all are hardback with nice covers. I kind of don't want to touch them. We'll see.
Glad to read through the posts so I can enjoy even if I can't participate.
1 reply · active 639 weeks ago
And it's your! UGH. grammer fail.
Boo, first half of CoS!

SO much is made of the whole mudblood/muggleborn thing that I wish more time in the series had been spent developing the squib-as-outsider. It would be much harder for the squib, I think: outcasts in the world they're born into, and unable to transition to the muggle world. By the time they're old enough to leave the wizarding world and live on their own, how would they know how to do *anything*? Dress normally, find a job, know how to use a telephone/electric kettle/the Tube/insert *anything* here?

Regarding Ron's wand: it can't be safe for a child to use a broken wand fixed with spellotape. and the weasleys cannot afford a new one--then that's just horrible classism. The well-off students can afford the materials they need to become qualified witches and wizards while the poor ones have to make do with second-hand everything, even if that means they cannot succeed in class?
10 replies · active 638 weeks ago
OH MY GOD Mrs. Norris from Mansfield Park is awful and probably the only entertaining character in that book. Maybe Filch pretends he's married to her?? Creepy.

And the wand thing is totally inconsistent. Ron said earlier that his wand used to belong to his brother, and there are other references to people getting new wands for no apparent reason but why would anybody get a new wand if wands are so well-suited to you? It's not like we get new body parts unless it's actually necessary.
1 reply · active 639 weeks ago
You poke those plot holes, sister. This is a safe place. Just be prepared for "Your mother was a hamster" insults if we can't think of any way to argue something into making sense.

Thanks goodness they figured out what proper detentions are.
1 reply · active 639 weeks ago
So much recapping! I quit reading because of the recaps the first time, and this time, in the first chapter, I kept thinking, "These aren't that bad," and then I realized that they JUST KEEP HAPPENING! I get it already!
1 reply · active 638 weeks ago
This is my least favorite of the series too though I was never quite able to say why...
1 reply · active 638 weeks ago
I like to imagine Filch curling up with a cup of tea and an Austen novel amid the torture chains in his office. What can I say, I'm a romantic...

Also, I prefer to pretend that Mrs. Norris was once a witch animagus (a la McGonagall) but somehow it went terribly wrong and now she's stuck as Filch's pet.
1 reply · active 638 weeks ago
This is seriously the worst book - I feel terrible for saying it, but I was too annoyed by all the new characters in the book, except for Gilderoy Lockhart. That man is fantabulous. Kenneth Branagh was PERFECT for the part. I also say this in a loving way.

HAHA "is Mrs. Norris a widow"? Girl, you are KILLING me! This is quality literature reflection right there.

AND YES, do plz blog all Ben Wyatt gifs <3
1 reply · active 638 weeks ago
Awww, even though Filch is horrible and annoying, you can't help but feel a little bad for him in this book. His life sucks and all he loves is his cat and then he totally breaks down because she gets all petrified :( Although I feel like I didn't care so much about that part before I became a cat-owner... odd.

I forget, how does Ron eventually get a new wand? Cause he needs one BAD, this one is a mess. And even though they're all poor and stuff I think his parents would be able to scrape up enough money to get it fixed or get a new one, you can hardly learn magic without a wand.
1 reply · active 638 weeks ago
Fun fact: I have never seen the Chamber of Secrets movie, so I don't know if Kenneth Branagh is good or not, but just, like, gif-wise... It seems like he really is!

I think that Harry would have preferred detention in the Forbidden Forest rather than with Lockhart. Just throwing that out there.

AND with Ron's wand... My assumption is that the wand place Harry goes to (nice work remembering the name of it, brain...) isn't the only place to get a wand from and you can get them secondhand and whatnot? I always kind of thought that the reason Ron was sort of awful at lessons was that he was too poor to get the wand that suited him. Or something.

And yeah, poor Filch. The grumpy bastard.
3 replies · active 638 weeks ago
OMG THAT FIRST GIF. I mean, Big Bang is officially Not Funny Anymore, but that gif is PERFECT. *steals it for later use*
1 reply · active 638 weeks ago
I know, poor Filch. Poor dude. BUT that is no excuse for trying to beat up children with whips and things. If he's so sad about being a Squib he could take off for foreign climes and live in the Muggle world, which? Is what I would do if I were a Squib. I'd go out into the Muggle world and like, invent an AIDS vaccine, and then the wizards would have to acknowledge that Squibs can be amazing.
2 replies · active 638 weeks ago
Ok, confession: I thought this book was a bit, er...slow, in the beginning too. I just kept thinking how had I been reading this ten+ years ago, I don't think I would have been all that enthralled with it.

Good point on the wand! You're right - I dont think you can just get a new wand "sent to you" (or in the case of my blog post - have Harry gift one to you) because the wand "chooses" you - at least that's what we learned in the first book!
1 reply · active 638 weeks ago

Post a new comment

Comments by