Thursday, October 8, 2015

The Monk part II: You possess my heart, but use not my gift ignobly

It's Thursday which means its time for another Monkalong post. Thank ya Alice, our fearless readalong leader.
I thought Part I of The Monk was nuts. Lewis wastes no time throwing us right into the temptation and craziness. So I thought maybe, just maybe, this next part would be calmer as we're dealing with the aftermath of Ambrosio and Matilda's transgressions.

NOPE!

Lewis doubles down on the insanity.
More insane than Neville looking like this
We spend most of the time with the Marquis Raymond (Agnes's baby daddy*) as he catches Lorenzo up with how exactly they got to where they are now. And OF COURSE the story is insane.

Raymond travels around under a fake name, so he can learn if people really like him for him, or just like him for his name/title. While traveling one night his chaise breaks down in the middle of the woods with nothing around for miles, because Lewis is the grandfather of urban legends. His servant tells him that coincidentally they are right near this guy he knows so don't worry, Raymond/Alphonse can spend the night there.

The man of the house, Baptiste, is very happy to have them, but the wife (Marguerite) seems cold and rude and Raymond tells Baptiste how sorry he is that this guy has to be married to such a bitch. Except that "bitch" later saves Raymond's life, so maybe she's owed an apology.

A baroness also gets a flat tire, or whatever is causing these breakdowns outside the house, and also ends up staying. Marguerite keeps acting weird, hissing at Raymond to check the sheets. Which he does and turns out THEY'RE COVERED IN BLOOD.
Marguerite does NOT fuck around when it comes to hints that something bad is going to happen. He then overhears his servant talking to Baptiste and they are the robbers everyone keeps talking about and they're planning on killing everyone and taking their stuff once the rest of the gang gets there.

Marguerite also warns Raymond not to drink the special champagne because it's drugged and he almost blows the whole thing but pretending to take a sip and then pretending to throw it all up (what?) and yet they still think he drank it all, which makes no sense. Then Marguerite has to remind Raymond to pretend to be passed out or they'll figure out he didn't actually drink it.

Marguerite and Raymond overpower Baptiste and murder him, and then get away with the passed out baroness, though sadly the servants staying in the barn are all murdered. But the rich people got out, and that's what matters.

Maggie then tells HER story about how she had married this other guy who was great, but a robber and that sucked and all. But then he died and the other robbers in the gang said she couldn't just leave and had to marry this asshole and she never got to see her kids and was kept a prisoner in the house. Now that she's free she decides to join a convent and asks that a couple strangers take care of the kids she LITERALLY JUST GOT BACK. And so her son Theo ends up traveling around with Raymond.

Raymond ends up hanging out with the baroness for awhile, where he meets Agnes. Agnes has been promised to the church since birth but they fall in love anyway. Except the baroness ALSO falls in love with Raymond. She declares her love for him but when he confesses that it's been a BIG misunderstanding and he's actually in love with someone else she gets RUHL pissed RUHL fast.
Agnes and Raymond make plans to run away together and the plans are insane. They involve Agnes dressing up like a BLOODY GHOST NUN and since everyone is super afraid of blood-drenched specters, nun or not, they figure this will totally work, and how convenient that this ghost apparently only shows up once every five years, but in a few days, it will be that time. Also they leave all the doors open for her so the ghost can move easily around the castle, even though she is a ghost. But it's for the best reason:

On that night the Porter always leaves the Gates of the Castle open, out of respect to the Apparition: Not that this is thought by any means necessary, since She could easily whip through the Keyhole of She chose it; But merely out of politeness, and to prevent her from making her exit in a way so derogatory to the dignity of her Ghost-ship.
"The Dignity of her Ghost-Ship" sounds like a song from a Mumford and Sons-like band.

They make plans to meet but instead of grabbing Agnes, Raymond grabs the ACTUAL ghost nun. He's not there to meet Agnes, who is super embarrassed that she has to go back to the castle and ask to be let back in, and everyone figures out what she was trying to do because ghosts don't need to knock.

Meanwhile, Raymond is now being haunted by this ghost. This mysterious figure shows up one day to tell Raymond that he knows how he can get rid of this ghost. It's actually an ancestor of Raymond's and she's pissed that she was never properly buried. Then we get bleeding ghost nun story, about how she was mistress for this one baron, but then decide she wanted his brother so she murdered baron number one and then was killed by baron's brother and her bones tossed in a pit. Raymond has to retrieve the bones and give them a proper burial at home in order to be free of her.

Agnes is now at this convent and Raymond finds her and disguises himself as a gardner. There are clandestine meetings and some sexy times but they are caught again! Agnes is pissed at Raymond and all seems lost until it turns out she's pregnant so she's decided to forgive him and they make the plans with the note left in the church where Lorenzo found him and now we're all caught up.

Lorenzo agrees to help Raymond (cos they're besties now) but the prioress won't let Lorenzo see his sister. Because she's busy torturing her because Ambrosio ratted her out. Eventually Lorenzo gets a note from a bull (or a papal bull, but I like my image of a bull pope) that will let Agnes not be a nun anymore but the prioress tells her "Oh yeah, sorry, I actually can't let you see your sister BECAUSE SHE'S DEAD."
Also there's a bit about Lorenzo going to ask Antonia's mom (Raymond's sister-in-law) if he can marry Antonia but Elvira says that he can but ONLY if Lorenzo's uncle agrees to the union and this part is so not interesting compared to ALL OF THE INSANITY THAT JUST HAPPENED.

I have no idea what's going to happen next. I assume Agnes isn't really dead. Actually, there were a few poems thrown in throughout this section and honestly they could (and prob did) tell the entire story but no, I did not read them. But beyond that I don't know that I can make any claims cos I would have never guessed "bleeding ghost nun" would be a major plot point, yet here we are.

There were so many good parts I highlighted to talk about but this is already super long so I will stop here. Will the insanity increase next week? I hope so.

*Right after I wrote this I turned to Tom to ask a "very important grammar question:" is "baby daddy" hyphenated? He looked at me, shook his head, told me he loved me, and went back to work. Which did not answer my question at all.

Title quote from location 2043

Lewis, Matthew Gregory. The Monk.

Comments (19)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Okay, I was super angry at this section of the book, but even I have to admit that taking the real ghost nun in his carriage instead of Agnes pretending to be the ghost nun was a good'un. Nice going, Matthew Lewis. That is as crazy as you could possibly have made it.
2 replies · active 492 weeks ago
I was looking up some GR reviews and people were talking about how boring this book was and all I could think was "BLEEDING GHOST NUN" and no, boring is not the right word for this. Unless you're talking about those poems cos no, I attempted the first one (ugh, I can't believe I need to differentiate cos there were multiple poems) and made it like 4 stanzas in before quitting. And I didn't try the second. If they want to say something to me, they can say it in prose.
Yeah, I skipped the poems mostly. What I did read was agonizing. Old Anacreon, seriously? (I know this about Anacreon: people liked to sing drinking songs about him. "Anacreon in Heaven" is the tune to the Star-Spangled Banner.)
I agree with you. It's not boring! He throws everything but the kitchen sink into his plot.

The Dignity of Her Ghostship would have a lot of banjos in it.
1 reply · active 492 weeks ago
So many banjos. I'm sure any concert featuring that song would also include a lot of flannel and beards and PBR. I'd still listen.

Everything about this section was nuts. The other sections can't match this insanity right? Cos that could get exhausting.
Oops, I've only just figured out the Matthew Lewis/Neville Longbottom thing. Silly Katie. Not joining the readalong but I read this at university when we did a Gothic Fiction course, and only exerpts were on the reading list but I went ahead and read the whole thing. Because I'm a super-swot like that! It was totally ridiculous but I kind of loved its outrageousness. Really enjoying your Monkalong posts so far.
1 reply · active 492 weeks ago
I wish I had read this in an academic setting. One that acknowledged the crazy in here because whoa this is way different than what I thought it would be. Glad you're enjoying the monkalong, active participant or no!
Wait, but I think she did get to see her kids, right? Because Theodore had been sick in bed upstairs. The thing that upset ME was they fled the house WITHOUT HER 3 YEAR OLD and just came back for him later.

That is the best use of that JLaw gif I've seen. Also, I feel like the dead nun story could've been its own book. I feel like a LOT of these stories could be their own book, but Lewis said "whatever THROW ALL THE IDEAS TOGETHER IN THE BOOK POT AND STIR."
2 replies · active 492 weeks ago
Ah I missed the part where the little kids were there. OK, so she's marginally better for abandoning her kids like 2 min later.

Lewis totally had an idea journal and then went "screw it" and throw everything into a single book.
I think she decided not to be a nun. Or somebody told her not to be. She got her dad's estate instead.
Agnes's baby’s daddy.

But the rich people got out, and that's what matters.

Tell it like it is!
2 replies · active 492 weeks ago
They can gussy it up with fancy language, but I think this is the crux of what's going on.
"Marguerite also warns Raymond not to drink the special champagne because it's drugged and he almost blows the whole thing but pretending to take a sip and then pretending to throw it all up (what?) and yet they still think he drank it all, which makes no sense. Then Marguerite has to remind Raymond to pretend to be passed out or they'll figure out he didn't actually drink it."

At this part I just wanted the book to be about ol Maggie, and then later I wanted it to be about the dynamic duo of Maggie and Ghost Nun. How awesome whould that be? So awesome.
1 reply · active 491 weeks ago
I'm actually surprised it took Maggie so long to get away, considering how clever we see her being. And that's from Raymond's point of view, and I think with the whole poisoning thing alone, he has proven himself to be kind of an idiot. So think of all the stuff she was up to that Raymond missed. Maggie & Ghost Nun foreva!
Duuuude, you are super into this, I love it. True, tis ridiculous but also WHY ARE WE HEARING ALL OF THIS IS IT RELEVANT?! IT IS NOT.

Was mainly what I got from this week's reading tbh haha. God that ghost nun thing was fucking mental though...
1 reply · active 491 weeks ago
I looooved this section. I know it was long and totally irrelevant to the Monk (unless Lewis somehow makes all of this bandit stuff double back on Rosario somehow) but it was so bonkers!!! I would way rather read all about the crazy baroness and the bleeding nun ghost than Ambrosio.

I did not expect the ghost nun to turn out to be real. Like, I figured it'd be a rumor or superstition and maybe weird things happen but you never get an actual answer about if it's real or not. And then Raymond accidentally grabs the wrong bloody nun and whaaaaa
Whoa there. I gotta stand up for my girl Marguerite. She planned to leave them in the care of their grandfather and join a convent because she didn't expect her dad to forgive her and that was the only way her kids could be provided for (because of the PATRIARCHY). But her dad told her definitely NOT to do that and welcomed her back like the Prodigal Daughter. She let her oldest son, Theodore, go with Raymond because he begged her. And she made Raymond promise to bring him back within a year. SHE IS A GOOD MOTHER.

Thank you for shirtless Matthew Lewis and Lee Pace in one post.
1 reply · active 491 weeks ago
I still question her letting Theo go with Raymond, who I guessssss helped save the day except he needed Maggie to walk him through every step and make sure he didn't screw up a few times. So begging or no, (kids beg for dumb shit all the time) she prob shouldn't have let him go.

Post a new comment

Comments by