Thursday, October 1, 2015

Mercy would here be criminal

Monkalong post one and I have actually managed to get the reading for the first post done on time!

I never know what to talk about in these first posts so why don't we start with what I knew about The Monk before starting the book:
Alright, good post.

So yeah, I didn't know anything about it other than Alice (aka Reading Rambo) said we're doing this readalong and yeah. I figure even if the book is not my thing the readalongs are always fun so it doesn't really matter what we read. Good thing so far this book is kicking ass.

First things first, we're all agreed that Aunt Leonella is the best, right?

Antonia, why do not you speak, Child? While the Cavalier says all sorts of civil things to you, you sit like a Statue, and never utter a syllable of thanks, either bad, good, or indifferent!
My dear Aunt, I am very sensible that...
Fye, Niece! How often have I told you, that you should never interrupt a Person who is speaking!? When did you ever know me to do such a thing?
The best.

(Also, does everyone's version have lots of words capitalized? Like not just first words of sentences and proper nouns? Is that a thing?)

So we have Antonia being boring and pretty, and Leonella being awesome and pushy and then two guys (Lorenzo and Christoval) being boring and falling in love with Antonia because of course. They, along with the whole of Madrid, are getting ready to listen to a sermon by the mystery priest Ambrosio. He's essentially a saint, having grown up with the monks after being left on their doorstep.

Too great severity is said to be Ambrosio's only fault. Exempted himself from human failings, He is not sufficiently indulgent to those of others

So you just KNOW he's going to have a fall from grace.

We transition from Lorenzo and Antonia via Lorenzo's sister, the nun Agnes. He falls asleep at the church and when the nuns come for confession he sees a man hide a letter, later picked up by his sister. But Ambrosio finds the letter and reads it cos being practically a saint means not respecting other people's mail. The letter informs Ambrosio that Agnes is planning on running away
with Antonia's uncle relative

because she is PREGNANT
Ambrosio tells the head nun who I believe literally dragged Agnes away promising various harsh punishments while Agnes yelled curses and the priest

Then we move into the next part of the story where Ambrosio thinks he's the best (Pride told him loudly that He was superior to the rest of his fellow-Creatures) and he even has this novice monk Rosario that is fawning over him.

Then it turns out that Rosario is dun dun DUUUUN...A WOMAN! Whaaaaaa?
She is madly in love with Ambrosio who agrees not to turn her in because she threatens to kill herself so yeah, lots of stable people here. He agrees to give her three days before she must leave and she agrees if he'll give her a flower but then he's BIT BY A DEADLY SERPENT and the Monk-doctor tells him he will totally be dead in three days. Except, he isn't. The swelling is gone and everything looks fine. But Matilda/Rosario is saying ominous things about how they'll never see each other again after three days and in truth she sucked the poison out so he could live. She uses the fact that she's about to die to convince Ambrosio to sleep with her and he does it because she reminds him of this version of the virgin Mary who has been giving him impure thoughts.

He forgot his vows, his sanctity, and his fame: He remembered nothing but the pleasure and opportunity.

We are only like 20% in and already Ambrosio has given into temptation. Lewis does NOT mess around.

What is going to happen with Ambrosio? And is Agnes OK? Is Leonella going to show up again and keep hitting on Christoval? Will the gypsy curse prove true and Antonia be killed? (Oh yeah, there's a gypsy curse. And a nun curse. THIS BOOK IS NUTS) How many more "gasp" gifs can I find, cos I'm thinking I'm going to need some more if this keeps up.

Comments (17)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
YES CAPITALIZING IS A THING please examine how English was influenced by German and the Germans capitalize all their nouns.

WE BOTH HAD MATTHEW LEWIS *AND* DONNA MEAGLE IN OUR POSTS

I find it highly fishy that Matilda was like "oh go get me a flower from right over there" and then BAM, deadly snake bite. *supports Matilda demon temptress theory*
3 replies · active 493 weeks ago
I thought about the German thing but then I was thinking that it's not like other books I've read from this time or earlier do the same capitalization thing. And this isn't capitalizing all of the nouns. Maybe it's just a bad copy...

I mean, Matthew Lewis, obv and Donna Meagle makes the BEST faces (I almost used the GIF you used) so I feel like she's going to show up again in this readalong.
Mine capitalizes most of the Nouns, yep. I think it's an 18th century thing but they were never as consistent as the Germans.
It's definitely an 18th Century thing, and I don't think they had a whole standardised thing yet? I just remember it annoying the SHIT out of me when I had to read this really terrible 18th C novel that has basically been forgotten for uni. URGH THE 18TH CENTURY.
I think it's going to be important going forward for us all to try and include at least one gif of Neville in each MONKALONG post. I didn't do that this time, and I regret it. Will rectify.
2 replies · active 492 weeks ago
I second the idea of Neville appearing in all of the Monkalong posts.
I solemnly swear that I will try to remember to do this henceforth.
The whole dream sequence in combination with the Gypsy Fortune Telling pretty much lays out the WHOLE BOOK for us and I am so astounded at M Lew's audacity. SEX IN CHAPTER TWO.

You are THE BEST AT GIFS.
1 reply · active 493 weeks ago
Thank you, thank you! I really thought we'd be building to a "will he/won't he succumb to temptation" and instead it was IMMEDIATE sexytimes.
I like that we get down to dirty business right away. Matilda knows what she wants and gets it!

I'm listening to audio (Librivox) but use the online version for quotes and "What did she say?" backup. Yes, the pronouns are even capitalized.
3 replies · active 493 weeks ago
Do we know how long Matilda had been hiding out as Rosario?

My copy's been very inconsistent with the capitalization. Sometimes pronouns and other nouns are capitalized, sometimes not.
I think maybe a year? I thought that was mentioned, but I could be totally wrong.
I think it might have been but I'm totally blanking. I was obv distracting by all the boob waving
Soon many gasping gifs required. It's just like the days of Wilkieeeeeeeee!

Leonella is amaaaaazing and I want her to have all the young husbands she desires! Also, "She is madly in love with Ambrosio who agrees not to turn her in because she threatens to kill herself so yeah, lots of stable people here." Hahaha, right?! Not a sane one among them, I reckon! PERFECT.
1 reply · active 493 weeks ago
I hope when Antonia shows up again she doesn't bring down this whole story by being normal and boring. ONLY CRAZY PEOPLE ALLOWED.
"So you just KNOW he's going to have a fall from grace." FOR sure, and also because his subtitle is "the Man of Holiness." No good ever comes of that.

Was Christoval also into Antonia? I thought he was just wing-man-ing for Lorenzo and that was how he ended up getting stuck with Leonella and her garlic hands. I want him to be too sensible to fall for Antonia. HE'S BETTER THAN THAT.
1 reply · active 492 weeks ago
I think I just assumed "boring beautiful woman" would mean eeeerrrrvryone is in love with her. But I think you're right, Christoval seems to have more sense

Post a new comment

Comments by