Thursday, June 5, 2014

You know the secret of my life

This is it, the final Lady Audley's Secret post. We shall see if all of our suspicions were correct. Thank you Alice for hosting this super fun time. Now to the spoilers and the gifs.

We ended the last chapter with Rob showing up very much NOT dead, though I'd like to imagine a bit singed, asking if he could have a word with Lady A. He makes a very dramatic announcement that Lady Audley set fire to the Castle Inn and...yeah. Was that not clear? Is that something that would have needed pointed out to the Victorian audience, or is this just more of MEB's sledgehammer? Anyway, Rob survived the inferno cos he wasn't asleep in his room. Which, OK. Bit anticlimactic but whatever.

Rob tells Lady A she has to confess to Sir Michael and we find out her other secret. She is a mad woman. Or I'm sorry MAD WOMAN. She killed George because SHE IS MAD! Except if you acknowledge that you're mad doesn't that mean you're sane enough to know it and thus not all that mad?

Lady A confesses a bunch of stuff, much of which we already know (Lady A = Helen Talboys, pushed George down well, was pretty pissed off over George's whole abandonment thing), some new stuff that we assumed (she was focused on marrying for money, her dad helped her fake her death), and stuff we didn't know (her mother was mad and it's the hereditary kind of madness). There were moments when I felt bad for her but then she had moments when you realize she's super selfish. Like when she learned that George was coming back from Australia and was trying to figure out how she was going to keep her rich life and she goes to scheme with her dad, where she meets Mrs. Plowson. This woman has the nerve to prattle on about her own insignificant problems which include a DYING CHILD.

I [Lady Audley] had miseries of my own, and worse miseries than her coarse nature could ever have to endure. These sort of people always had sick husbands or sick children, and expected to be helped in their illness by the rich.

Ugh poor people, always whining about how their children are dying or how they have no money for food. Wah wah wah. Don't they know that Lady A could end up poorer than she is now?? Her problems are WAY WORSE. Of course then she realized that she could use this tragedy for her own gain. She makes some comment about how the girl, Mathilda, wasn't going to last a fortnight and George was due back in 3 weeks and ISN'T THAT CONVENIENT??
I'm going to choose to believe that's not lazy storytelling and just add it to Lady A's death count.

Although Lady A hasn't actually confessed to pushing George down the well and I really thought there was going to be some technicality there, but no, she just saves that confession for later. I dunno why we had to hold on to that.

After hearing the confession Sir Michael silently walks out of the room and has a bit of a nervous breakdown. Rob is afraid he's going to have a heart attack when the shock wears off. He has Alicia keep an eye on Sir Michael as they pack to get away from Audley Court. They'll spend some time traveling around Europe. Meanwhile Rob has to deal with Lady A.

He ships her off to a sanatorium in Belgium. But he takes her there so that's pretty nice of him. And he makes sure to set her up in I guess a nice sanatorium. Now she doesn't have to go to court and thus Sir Michael isn't shamed but she still gets punished. Kinda.

Clara, who has not been present nearly enough, sends Rob a letter telling him he has to come visit Luke Marks cos Luke is dying and wants to see him. I'm not sure exactly how it works out that Clara is the one sending this message but I'm going to assume she already has things figured out and is trying to guide Rob the right way. Considering how fast she figured out the Lady A bit, I wouldn't be surprised if this is the case.

Rob goes to talk to Luke and GUESS WHAT! George did fall down the well but he crawled back up. Yup, crawled right up the well. The extra deep and empty well. With a broken arm.
Because I guess George is like that chick from The Ring. Luke found George hiding in the bushes and helped clean him up and get him a doctor. Then he was supposed to deliver 2 letters, one to Lady A and one to Rob, letting them know George is alive but ran away to Australia again. Except Luke wanted to keep blackmailing Lady A and didn't know who Rob was so nothing got delivered. Luke, you suck.

Rob tells Clara George is alive...somewhere. Probably Australia. Clara tells her dad, who remains nonplussed. Rob goes to stay with George's dad and Clara for...reasons? I'm not really sure. But it does give him the opportunity to sort of compliment Clara by saying things like:

[Clara was] more beautiful than the morning - for that was sometimes dull and cloudy, while she was always fresh and bright.

Thanks, Rob. I'm sure Clara likes being told "You're more beautiful than a really dreary morning." I'm sure he followed that up with things like "I like her even better than cold, weak tea."

I have noticed that in all of Clara's interactions with Rob in none of them does she display any affection for him. It's all "Avenge my brother, or I'll do it" and "Haven't you figured this out yet?" and "Man, you are wasting your life. Have you thought about not doing that?" He proposes to her, awkwardly, and her response is to just slowly pull her hand out of his. This by the way, right after he said he'd go search Australia for George if she would marry him, so yeah her hesitation makes sense.

Turns out Rob doesn't need to go to Australia to try to find George (which I assume would have ended up with Rob wandering around yelling "George" and eventually getting bitten by SOMETHING poisonous) because George is just chilling in Rob's London apartment. Just haaaaanging out.
Turns out he decided not to go back to Australia and hung out in New York for awhile before coming back at a super convenient time because he "yearned for the strong grasp of your hand, Bob." Good thing everyone has impeccable timing because this would have been awkward if he just missed Rob, who had boarded a boat headed for Australia. BUT THEN we could have gotten the Victorian equivalent of someone racing to the gate to stop him from leaving, so that could have been fun. Missed opportunity, MEB.

Rob and Clara end up married and they live together with George and Georgey so I'm going to assume that Clara is just the beard but at least now George and Rob and be together and raise Georgey together and that is adorable. Oh and Alicia married that other guy that she didn't really seem to care for but everyone has to be paired off, even if the woman doesn't care for him so fine. Whatever. Maybe Clara and Alicia are secretly together. And Lady A dies in the sanatorium. The end.

So what'd we think? I think we've read too many mysteries cos I mean, I am BAD at guessing what's coming next in a mystery. Which is good for me cos then I'm surprised exactly when the storyteller wants me to be. But here, we guessed it fairly early on which meant a lot of the time was spent waiting for the characters to catch up. I liked it but I wanted there to be more twists, more mystery. But I was entertained so kudos MEB.

Title quote from page 233, location 4532

Braddon, Mary Elizabeth. Lady Audley's Secret. Amazon Digital Services. Originally published 1862.

Comments (17)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
"Thanks, Rob. I'm sure Clara likes being told "You're more beautiful than a really dreary morning.""

Ahahahahaha

Yeah, it wasn't that good. BUT now we've read it. I think maybe it'd be better if you kind of just sat down and read through it quickly? But because we had a MONTH to ponder it all and be like 'Waiiit, MEB" all its flaws became reeeal apparent.
2 replies · active 561 weeks ago
I agree if we had less time to think about this we prob would have thought it was a better book. And prob wouldn't have figured out the mystery so far ahead of time.

I would like to point out that Rob is pretty good at complimenting George. Clara though, not so much.
I third this. This is the sort of book to race through and not really think about really hard.

Also, CLIMBED OUT OF A DEEP DARK WELL WITH A BROKEN ARM WTAF.
It's never really explained how George dragged himself back up the well, is it? It's not even actually said that she pushed him down there, although it's probably safe to assume it. MEB seems to over-explain the simple things and just not bother explaining the interesting stuff!

I'm rubbish at figuring out this stuff too. I didn't even click on when everybody else did that Lady A had CLEARLY shoved him down the well. There were practically neon arrows flashing at the damn thing and I STILL missed it.
5 replies · active 561 weeks ago
Lady A eventually admits to pushing George down the well, but only to Rob. I dunno why she holds that part till later. And she only sorta pushed him. It was more like he was leaning on something over the well and she moved that. Which explains how such a light-weight like her could do that. But she does make a comment about how it took a really long time for him to hit the bottom and there was no water so no splash, just a thud. So really, he should NOT have crawled back up that well...

Yeah I totally didn't think of the well until this readalong pointed it out. I'd like to think though that I would still have figured it out before Rob. Stupid Rob
Does she? Why don't I remember this part? It does make more sense than her outright shoving him down there, I suppose. He MIGHT have been able to brace his back against the wall and kind of walk up it with his legs (or that's how I'd try and do it, because I CLEARLY have years of well-climbing experience :s ) but not if it was that deep a well.

I'm right in thinking that MEB DIDN'T explain how he managed it, though?
I don't think he explained how he did it. Especially not with that arm. If anything it might have been that bracing thing you mentioned. Of course I could just be thinking that cos you mentioned it and now it makes sense that he COULD do it that way. I guess you wouldn't need an arm for that?
He said the rocks were rough enough that he was able to find foot and handholds and then brace his back and legs against the sides when he needed a rest. He EXPLAINED this, you guys.
So he gets handholds which he can only kinda use cos his arm's broken. Which he does not address. MEB soooorta explained it. But with holes. Many holes.
"Except if you acknowledge that you're mad doesn't that mean you're sane enough to know it and thus not all that mad? I thought the same thing! She's way too clear headed about it.

I think Clara was hanging out with the town's minister and that's why she knew about Luke (remember her organ playing?)

She is totally a beard for the real couple in this romance.
1 reply · active 561 weeks ago
I wonder if she was thinking this madness thing would really save her and then that backfired, didn't it?

Ah right, the minister. That guy would probably know what's going on.

Rob and George are raising a kid together with George's sister's help. That's what's happening here.
"Turns out Rob doesn't need to go to Australia to try to find George (which I assume would have ended up with Rob wandering around yelling "George" and eventually getting bitten by SOMETHING poisonous)..." AHAHAHAHA. The man can't even stay upright on ice skates. Australia would chew him up and spit him out, you are so right.

I like to think that Alicia really did love Harry Towers, but she was too blinded by her infatuation with Rob to acknowledge it at the time of the marriage proposal.

Also, there was a lot of Victorian CAPS lock in this book.
1 reply · active 561 weeks ago
The adventures of George and Rob in Australia would be fun to watch. I bet George would end up saving Rob all the time cos he'd constantly be wandering into croc infested rivers. But then Rob would keep having to watch George to make sure he wouldn't wander off somewhere, as is his tendency.
Ahaha, the bit where Robert announces who set the fire was amazing. "should I tell you who did it, Lady A? Shall I? IT WAS YOU!' No shit, Sherlock.

Ah, the nice kind of sanatorium you can never leave and you die in because you're REALLY BORED. I don't like Lucy even now, but I still didn't really want that for her! I don't know what I wanted.

Ahhhhhh, I missed the part where George missed the strong grasp of Robert's hand!!!!! SO DIRTY.
1 reply · active 561 weeks ago
This sanatorium (as described in the book and not based on the real world) seems nicer than a prison Lucy would have ended up in if they did the whole trial thing. So I dunno, between the 2 that didn't seem so bad. Though I still think Lucy should have told Sir Michael that Rob was crazy and get HIM sent to a madhouse. I'm sure Lucy wouldn't have picked a nice one.

I loooved the line from George about Rob's strong hand cos CLEARLY throughout the book we see Rob's love for George. But since George was only around to mope we didn't get to see him fawn over Rob. This was a nice reminder of their love. And a reminder that Rob & Clara are just a cover
>>Turns out Rob doesn't need to go to Australia to try to find George (which I assume would have ended up with Rob wandering around yelling "George" and eventually getting bitten by SOMETHING poisonous)

I laughed very hard at this. I imagine him being like Dean in Supernatural wandering around screaming Sam's name like he do. Or whatshisface in Lost, the father, who was always wandering about the island screaming WAAAAAAAAALT for his kid.
1 reply · active 561 weeks ago
Right? He would have figured he was this great detective after the whole Lady A thing and then he'd get down there and be lost. I think he sort of knew this when he told Clara she should come. He knows he needs her.

Post a new comment

Comments by