Friday, February 8, 2013

Nasty temper he's got, that Sirius Black

Happy Friday/Harry Potter Readalong Day! AND we're starting one of my favorite Harry Potter's (behind Order of the Phoenix anyway), Prisoner of Azkaban. Stuff starts getting darker, we get introduced to new characters THAT I LOVE, and there's that hippogriff.
Thank you Alice for holding this thing and a reminder to everyone that there will be spoilers. Be prepared. Also I heart this books so WEEEEEE
Photobucket
It was nice to see Harry (somewhat) stand up to the Dursleys, or at least his Aunt Marge. Plus it worked out nicely that he didn't get in trouble for it. See, there are POSITIVE side effects to an Azkaban escapee searching for you.

Finally the wizarding community decided to forgive Hagrid and make him a teacher. I mean, it would have been nice of them if they had forgiven Hagrid after it became clear Tom Riddle = Voldemort and thus Hagrid didn't set the basilisk loose. But I think it's clear the wizarding world has a terrible legal system.

Speaking of the wizard legal system, they are not focused on rehabilitation at all with their prison system. And considering they sent a small child to Azkaban because they thought he opened the Chamber of Secrets (on the word of another child instead of any sort of investigation) so I guess this really shouldn't be a surprise.  Rowling did create a supremely creepy creature in the Dementors. And I like that chocolate helps with the after effects. Because mmmmmm chocolate.
Photobucket
I know it was a bad thing for Buckbeak to attack Malfoy, but man, don't you kinda wish he took off his whole arm or something? Maybe just a finger. Also Malfoy's threat about his dad going to the school governors seems empty. You know, given Lucius was kicked off the board for blackmail and intimidation.

Lupin is great (even if I have problems with his name, which will be dealt with at a later time). It's nice to see an actually competent teacher. I know there are a few at the school, but they seem in equal number to the useless ones. Even if I like the useless ones. Like Trelawney. I mostly like Trelawney because of Emma Thompson and for her banter with McGonagall.

The Marauder's Map is super creepy. Awesome if you're the one that has it and creepy if you're anyone. Because it knows where you are at all times.
Photobucket
Then there's the whole danger factor considering people want to get into the schools and maybe this isn't a good thing to have around.

Concerning the Firebolt, Harry and Ron are dumbasses. They know Black was in the castle and they acknowledge he's coming for Harry. Yet he gets a VERY expensive broomstick and has no concerns over it. Teenagers are stupid and they need to stop yelling at Hermione.

Also the idea that Dumbledore couldn't be the one that gave him the broomstick because that would be showing favoritism. Except that time he bent the rules to let him play on the house team. And gave him his first broomstick, which was top of the line at the time. But no, no favoritism.

As with the other books, the second half is the best part so I can't wait until part II!

Title quote from page 161

Rowling, J.K. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban. Scholastic, 1999.

Comments (32)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
"But I think it's clear the wizarding world has a terrible legal system."

Ahahahaha truth. Remember in the future when Harry's brought before a tribunal and it's ridiculous? I do. Silly wizards.
2 replies · active 632 weeks ago
HOW did I forget to talk about the chocolate?! I wish my school nurse had handed out chocolate while I was growing up, I would have been there ALL the time. And probably taking chocolate vitamins too, just in case. Because I don't do that now or anything. Okay, FINE, I had chocolate chip muffins for breakfast. WHAT IS THE PROBLEM.

Aww, poor Hermione, everyone's so MEAN to her in this book and she's just doing her best, ya know? And I would love to know you're problems with Lupin's name - is it just that it's so obvious, because everybody's names are. Okay, not everyone, but Sirius's is too.
10 replies · active 632 weeks ago
I love that Harry blew up at the Dursleys - or rather, blew one of them up.
Chocolate solves everything, and JKR validates that fact fantastically.
I love Lupin - sigh. Brainy AND kind, minus the usual social awkwardness (wait. He is a bit awkward. a bit. even better.)

Teenagers are stupid, and so incredibly mean. Sure, Hermione tends to get annoying, but she was acting to protect them.
1 reply · active 632 weeks ago
See, I don't understand WHY Harry would have gotten into trouble when it was total accidental magic- surely that doesn't count? Like when he did it accidentally when he was a kid? HELP ME OUT HERE!

Daaaamn, I would have loved it if Buckbeak had taken off Malfoy's arm. Maybe next time... (loljk clearly never happens)

Whyyyy do you have issues with Lupin's name? I NEED TO KNOW!
1 reply · active 632 weeks ago
I would have had major issues if Hagrid's incompetence had resulted in a student's arm being severed. Even if that student were Malfoy. Malfoy is an asshole but hagrid is a danger to society. His good intentions notwithstanding.
1 reply · active 632 weeks ago
I love Hermione, but I think this is the book where I start to realise "oh, if she doesn't get it, then it's invalid". The stuff with Trelawney is a nice little prelude to Luna, who might be a little weird and off with the fairies but is still an intelligent and wonderful person who has feelings. So it makes her a little more human, but it also makes me feel a little sorry for her and the fact that she has so little appreciation for imagination - in spite of the fact that she became a witch when she would have grown up thinking they were things out of story books.
2 replies · active 632 weeks ago
I like Lupin too. But I feel a big story about him uncovering soon...either Snape is trying to kill him or Lupin is actually evil too. I really hope not. He seems like someone Harry can finally trust to confide in.

How do the xmas presents get to the end of beds?! That's what I want to know! Does that mean anybody can send a gift to a student by using magic? You'd think bad things could be sent to the school all the time then! Like....if Sirius really wants to kill Harry, couldn't he send a bomb package?!
3 replies · active 632 weeks ago
I get stupid about this book. And the film. Because basically my thoughts just pan down to "OMG that flight with Buckbeak makes me cry", "OMG I want to marry Lupin", "OMG Sirius is awesome later so we'll ignore him being a bit psychotic" and "OMG JOHN WILLIAMS THIS IS MY FAVOURITEST SOUNDTRACK". With maybe a bit more crying because of the whole Marauders being back together thing and Harry finding out more about his mum and dad and having these surrogate uncle figures kind of gathering out of nowhere... and then I go read FanFiction instead because then you get more Marauders and less death. I KNOW I KNOW.
1 reply · active 632 weeks ago
The Dementors are so good. Soer creepy. And I love that Ginny is affected so much by them on the train. JKR's trying to remind us what she went through even if the other characters have forgotten. (That Tumblr Ginny post Alice linked to the other week as GOTTEN to me!)
1 reply · active 632 weeks ago

Post a new comment

Comments by