Wednesday, August 22, 2012

For your own sake, get on with your grog

It's Wednesday again, so here we are again to discuss The Moonstone as part of Alice's readalong. Are you excited? You should be. Unless you aren't playing along in which case these posts are probably annoying to you. Sorry about that. Anyway, onto Wilkie!

First up, we get MOAR CLACK!
Photobucket
I thought we were done with her after the last section but she's back for more. After Lady V's death Rachel goes to hang out with Godfrey's family cos apparently Rachel must be guarded at all times. And for whatever reason she invites Clack to hang out with her, which is a win for us, but I can't figure out why exactly she wants her there. Other than we need Clack to tell us what happens during this scene because there is BIG NEWS. (Also the opium.)

Remember how we ended the last section all going "Rachel and Godfrey are engaged, whaaaaa?" Rachel has come to her senses and broken off the engagement and with no reason. Well no reason she'll tell anyone, because being stubborn is her thing apparently. Godfrey's dad is NOT having this and the scene is all tense and angry and he's face is going red and there's a lot of yelling. Clack is there to break the tension though with a tract! She apparently carries tracts for all occasions and his occasion calls for "Hush, for Heaven's Sake!" You know all that frustration everyone felt about her but were too nice to say? Daddy Godfrey isn't too nice. He calls her an "impudent fanatic" and "Rampant Spinster" and kicks Rachel out of his house. Don't worry though, because Mr. Bruff agrees to take her in and also Clack has decided she'll leave Rachel a whole bunch of tracts in her will.

Next we move into Bruff's narrative and we don't get too much here except the knowledge that those three Indians that I keep forgetting about are still after the diamond and they found out that they're going to have to wait a year because it's currently being used as collateral for a loan. We also learn that SOMEONE wanted to take a look at Lady V's will not long after she passed and that SOMEONE proposed to Rachel because that SOMEONE is Godfrey! Because we were all totally right that Godfrey should not be trusted. Bruff tells Rachel about this and Rachel breaks off the engagement and now we're finally getting some answers.

And we're about to get some more answers because our next narrative is by Franklin! We learn what's in Rosanna's letter and what she put in the Shivering Sand! Except everything we find out causes more questions and we all need more grog.
Rosanna really was in love with Franklin and she was totally neglectful of Lucy and my dreams were crushed a little.
It was a nightgown in the Shivering Sand. The nightgown with the pain smear. And that nightgown belonged to....FRANKLIN! Whaaaa?
Whaa?
No seriously, what? Cos Franklin says he must have done it because I mean, there's his nightgown with the stain so irrefutable evidence right there. And he just doesn't remember it.
Rachel broke it off with Franklin and refuses to speak to him because she SAW HIM steal the Moonstone.
But they still want to be together! But they can't because she sees him as a thief and he knows he didn't do it and has to prove it to her and then they walk away from each other and the section we're supposed to read ends! BUT I NEED TO KNOW WHAT HAPPENS NEXT!
Photobucket
How is this going to play out? Did Franklin really steal the Moonstone? And does he actually not remember taking it? Or is this all part of his con?
Why did Godfrey look at the will? What's his end game?
Who is using the diamond as collateral? And for what?
What about those Indians that keep randomly showing up whenever I have forgotten about them?

Wilkie! Tell me your secrets!

Title quote from page 158, location 5142

Collins, Wilkie. The Moonstone. Public domain books, published 2012. Originally published 1868

Comments (22)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I WANT CLACK TO LEAVE ME TRACTS IN HER WILL

Poor Indians. Always being forgotten.

ALSO, we did not discuss how Franklin ATTACKS RACHEL'S FACE WITH HIS MOUTH and how it was 1849 in the story and they are NOT engaged, and if you watch enough Austen miniseries you know that in 1815 you couldn't even kiss when you were engaged, so daaaaamn, Franklin.
2 replies · active 655 weeks ago
YES about Rachel and the face sucking. During that whole scene I just kept thinking "NOW KISS" but I didn't expect him to hear me. Franklin, you crazy
I'll bet that scene was all shocking for the time and whatnot. Especially since he pulls out the whole fanfic cliche of her being into it for a sec before pushing him away. IT'S THE BEST.
Betteredge would just say Franklin's Italian or French side briefly took charge and he was FULL OF FEELINGS.

The Indians are starting to feel like an unnecessary plot device. There's so much going on, that we don't really "need" them.
2 replies · active 655 weeks ago
I have faith that Wilkie is going to do something spectacular with the mystery Indians. He better anyway.
A good author always utilizes his mystery Indians.
SHOCKED KITTY!!

Ahem. I totally forget about the Indians because I'm like 'well, *clearly* they didn't do it, because otherwise they would have it' but.... if Wilkie wants to play it like they all get it back in the end then, hey, I'm cool with that.

I kind of liked daddy Godfrey, because OH how Clack needed telling off. It was pretty fun :)
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
I felt so bad for Clack cos I mean, she needed told off but like that? Poor lady. I'm sure she has a tract for what happened though. Cos she carries a selection with her at all times, which was probably my favorite thing to learn about her.
It sounds like you are really enjoying the novel! Looking forward to what you think of the ending :)
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
I cannot wait for the ending! Because after this latest section I have no idea what's going to happen.
I can't read any of this and it is killing me. And me, the dumb kid that I am, didn't participate even though the damn thing is on my classics club list. Shakes fist in the air (at self). Anyway. It looks like you, and the rest of the group, are loving it. Jealous & happy for you.
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
Well when you DO get around to reading it, I cannot wait for your post about because this book is amazing. I am sad you're missing out on the readalong. But there will be more!
"Clack has decided she'll leave Rachel a whole bunch of tracts in her will."

Oh man, most disappointing inheritance ever.

I'm 95% sure that Franklin didn't actually steal the diamond, but I'm hoping the solution doesn't make Rachel look like an idiot. I'm starting to actually like her.

Also, I can't stop watching the shocked!cat.
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
I was worried about Rachel looking like an idiot if/when it turns out Franklin didn't steal the diamond. Like she was TOTALLY mistaken about it being him and it's actually Ezra or one of the Indians or Rosanna or something very obviously not Franklin. Egg on her face and all.
Why DOES everyone put up with the Clack? Like when Mr. Ablewhite calls her a Rampant Spinster and Rachel puffs out her chest and declares that Clack is HER guest. That's sweet, Rachel...but no. Don't defend the crazy lady in the corner.

MOAR GROG!
1 reply · active 655 weeks ago
Right?? I mean hooray because we learn that Clack carries a slew of tracts with her at all times but I can't figure out why Rachel wants Clack around. Though I do think she stood up for Clack to Mr. Ablewhite mostly to disagree with him.

Mmmm grog
Oh, Daddy Godfrey, your head colour betrays your feels. That scene was so funny. I think Rachel was just trying to be nice to Clack because her mom was nice to Clack. And Lady V was nice to Clack because she was a LADY and had the patience of a SAINT. Oh, Lady V, we miss you.

Who is using the diamond as collateral, indeed! It's killing me a little bit. I might have to speed read at lunch.
2 replies · active 655 weeks ago
Hmm...I accept this explanation of Clack's continued presence. *I* would not have been so kind, I'm afraid.
Yeah, that makes sense. And Lady V was a saint. And she made sure to keep Rachel's money was safe from cads. I want to hear more from Lady V.

Post a new comment

Comments by