Wednesday, January 8, 2014

Prison is so much about the people who are missing from your life and who fill your imagination

I realize I haven't talked about my love for the Netflix show Orange is the New Black here, although if you follow me on Twitter you've probably seen some ALL CAPS declarations of love. Because it's an amazing show and if you haven't seen it yet, you should probably drop what you're doing and go binge watch. It's hilarious and touching and complicated and OMG I LOVE IT. So reading the book that inspired it seemed like a natural choice. Especially when said book was on sale.

The original Orange is the New Black is a memoir by Piper Kerman, as WASP from a good New England family who, in her early twenties Piper dated a woman who dealt heroin for some guy in West Africa. She didn't deal heroin in the "stand on a street corner" kind of way, but instead the way that let her jet set to exotic locations and have lots of disposable income. Piper laundered money for the operation one time and ten years later found herself serving a 15 month sentence at a minimum security prison. Piper's memoir details what she learned about herself, about the other women she was incarcerated with, and about the American prison system. Things about herself and other women: pretty good. The prison system:...yeah, not so much.

Laura pointed this out in her review that Kerman does an excellent job talking about all of the problems with the prison system without smacking you over the head with them. She's so right. Kerman points out things that are messed up in the prison system, be it conditions or who is predominantly being arrested, without preaching. And they're woven within the story itself so they never get eye-rolly. And some of the stuff is terrible and unfair
"A female prisoner who alleges sexual misconduct on the part of a guard is invariably locked in the SHU [solitary confinement] in 'protective custody,' losing her housing assignment, program activities (if there are any), work assignment, and a host of other prison privileges, not to mention the comfort of her routine and friends."

There are a lot of funny moments that come from the ridiculousness of the situation.
"Nice veins!" [the prison doctor] said with very genuine admiration. "No track marks!" Given his total lack of irony, I thanked him.

Reading this made me want to watch the show all over again. It's different enough that you shouldn't expect to read the same thing as the show, but there are enough moments and characters that are the same or at least similar enough to make me go "TAYSTEE I MISS YOU".

I know there are complaints that the book only focuses on Piper's experience so you're only seeing prison through the eyes of a white upper-middle-class woman. Those people are dumbasses. You've picked up a memoir by a white upper-middle-class woman. The hell did you think it was going to be about? I know the show branches out more and that is AWESOME and a big plus for the show. But really, why did you think Piper's memoir would also include memoirs from other ladies?

Piper does come off a bit like her shit smells like flowers, but not enough that I was mad at her for it. I mean I assume when it comes to memoirs most people are painting themselves with some pretty rose colored glasses. I would. Again, another way I appreciate that the TV show, since it's not Piper's memoirs, can branch out from this, but I really don't think it's something to hold against the book.

I really enjoyed the book. It's one I could see my re-reading. However, the show is still better. Just don't go into the book expecting to get the same experience as the show. Which is probably good advice in general when seeing a story in multiple media.

Title quote from page 107, location 1690

Kerman, Piper. Orange is the New Black: My Year in a Women's Prison. Spiegal & Grou, 2011. Kindle edition.

Comments (16)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
This year makes me happy IF ONLY because we're getting a new season of OITNB. Remember when we finished last summer and had to wait a year? WE NOW HAVE TO WAIT LESS TIME.

"You've picked up a memoir by a white upper-middle-class woman. The hell did you think it was going to be about?"

Oooh, good point. Also: TAYSTEEEEEEEE.
3 replies · active 589 weeks ago
I CAN'T WAIT for OitNB. I need more Taystee and Poussey. And I guess Piper and Alex but whatever.

I think the show is better cos it can show POVs that aren't "white lady in jail" but I can't fault Piper's memoir of being about that.
WHEN WILL POUSSEY TELL TAYSTEE HOW SHE FEELS AND HOW WILL TAYSTEE REACT I CAN'T HANDLE EEEEEEEEEEET

Because like 92% sure Taystee's straight. But Poussey's FEELIIIIIINGS.
YES, AGREED ON ALL OF THAT. I want Poussey to tell Taystee but I don't want her to get hurt.
I just miss Crazy Eyes. Susanna is one of THE BEST characters on this show, and her comedy never seems to get the love it needs.

And I know when I read a memoir, I expect it to contain many life stories, maybe not even the one about the person listed as the author of the memoir. I'm eternally confused as to why THIS hasn't caught on as the next great memoir publishing trend of 2014.
1 reply · active 589 weeks ago
I looooved Susanna. Really, I love them all (but especially Taystee and Poussey).

I mean I can see people saying "I like the show better than the book because it shows so many dif POVs" because agreed. But being disappointed because it only tells Piper's story seems silly.
I read this over Christmas and wasn't sure if I'd like it since Piper is my least favourite character in the show, but I thought it was pretty interesting. Although, I can kind of understand the complaints about it being from her perspective, only because the show does such a good job of fleshing out the other characters and telling their stories and I really missed that element.
3 replies · active 589 weeks ago
Agreed that I was sort of skeptical cos yeah, Piper isn't my fav. But I was happy to like it as much as I did.

I get not enjoying the book as much as the show because it's from different perspectives and those other perspectives are awesome. But I dunno, it seems like a weird complaint to make when you know going into the book that it's only going to be Piper's story. It's a bit like complaining if a Stephen King story is scary. Right, that's what you should go in expecting. It just seems like a weird thing to hold against the book.
Oh for sure, there's no way you could possibly go into the book without knowing it was going to be all/mostly from her perspective, and that's definitely a stupid criticism. I saw some reviews like that on Goodreads, and others which complained that she didn't talk about the problems in the prison system, while she clearly did and I actually thought was one of the strengths in the book.
Maybe cos she subtly talked about the problems with the prison system people missed it? Maybe they needed full chapters dedicated to it.
Aaaaaaaa I need to watch Orange Is the New Black but I also don't want to watch it right away because what if a little while later I really want to watch something awesome but I've burned through all of OITNB already?
1 reply · active 589 weeks ago
YES YOU DO! And the answer to your question is simple: you rewatch OitNB. OR I suppose you could wait till this summer when season 2 is released and then watch both of them at once
I've been wanting to read this. Like you I loved the show, but I definitely don't think the book will be exactly like it.
1 reply · active 589 weeks ago
I think as long as you go into it knowing that the book won't be just like the show then you're good. Cos it's not and I still like the show better, but the book is still an entertaining read
Yaaaaay, I'm glad you liked the book! The show is definitely better (DEFINITELY) but the book is still preeeetty good, and I liked reading it and being like 'Jenji Kohan, I see where you started from and I like what you did with it.'

Taystee was in Girls last night (or, ok, I watched it this morning) and I was honestly like OH MY GAAAAAAAAAHH!!! I love her so.
1 reply · active 588 weeks ago
Aww was Taystee amazing on Girls? (Silly question, cos OBV she was.)

Agreed that I liked reading the book and being like "ah HA! I see where that part of the show came from." Cos yeah, the show is better but it gets to tell lots of stories so of course it's better. I am curious how the ending of the book will play out on the show, if at all.

Post a new comment

Comments by