Wednesday, April 24, 2013

My parents were now a dim Italian and a performing monkey

Puppet Shows is a collection of short stories. It reads like someone just recorded every fever dream they had and then put them together in a book. Whether or not that sounds like something you'd like to read is up to you.

Personally, I'm not a fan of listening to other people's dreams, in the real world or in books. Maybe it's because I have trouble following them, or because they aren't nearly as interesting to the listener as they were to the dreamer.* I think it's the following thing mostly the "I can't follow them" thing because there is no logic to them. Things just happen and then suddenly something else happens and then a third thing happens that is unrelated to the first two things, the end.

As I said, the book is a collection of short stories, which is always difficult for me to review. Normally I review a couple of the stories. But these stories sort of blend together.(by being a series of non-sequiturs, not because they all reference each other) so I'll try to take this collection on as a whole.

The stories actually started out normal enough. Well as normal as a story about a boy raised by a talking racist monkey and an Italian organ grinder stereotype after his drunk and abusive Klingon loving father spontaneously combusted, leaving him an orphan. Yes, that's the part of the story I could follow. You tell me that this is the story, fine, I can get behind it. Maybe set up a few rules so I can follow this twisted world, but I can get behind this. But there are no rules and there is no reason and suddenly a guy having an awkward dinner with his racist grandfather when General Tso appears out of no where and murders the old man. And that's it. Story over. There's no rules and no explanation and I spent a lot of this book dealing with literary whiplash as I tried to catch up. Eventually I realized there was nothing to catch up to. I was there, I just had no idea where "there" was.

After finishing the series I read a couple people refer to the stories as "slapstick" and similar to a Punch and Judy play. I an see that. At least from what I know of Punch and Judy, which isn't much. There's a lot of violence but it's so ridiculous it's nothing you can take seriously. That doesn't mean I'm enjoying it, just that it isn't disturbing violence. It's like watching The Three Stooges. If you find them funny, this might be the thing for you. Maybe. I know as much about the Stooges as I do about P&J so, yeah.

For example, there are lines like this, which happen during a strange dinner party with a couple doctors and patients:
"Doctor Milano noticed three men bouncing around the room, hooting like Daffy Duck, until Doctor Rossi hit one on the head with a frying pan and shot the other two with a tranquilizer gun."

So yeah, if you like slapstick violence, crazy non-sequiturs, and a general feeling that you're listening to the rambling fever dreams of someone tripping, this could be a book for you! Unfortunately, it was not the bok for me.

*Please read the Cracked list 5 Things You Love to Discuss That Nobody Else Cares About to see I'm not alone in this.

Title quote from page 9

Frissore, Michael. Puppet Shows. AMuse Me Publishing, 2012. ebook. I agreed to read this in exchange for an honest review.

Comments (25)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Haha yes, listening to someone else's dreams can be tough. I do make an exception if they say I was in their dream (and possibly did something incredibly stupid or strange), it can be fun to listen to those.
1 reply · active 622 weeks ago
I'm certainly MORE interested if I'm involved, but even then I think I'd zone out halfway through.
The only thing I've read like this is Nabokov's An Invitation to a Beheading, which is INSANE but also I keep thinking about it soooo maybe it won.
3 replies · active 622 weeks ago
Do you think about it in a good way or in a "wtf was that about way?"
Hmmmm. When I took my Dickens course, at the end of it I was SO sick of knowing what had to happen next because of Victorian morality that I was thrilled to look at Invitation again. I keep meaning to re-read it.
Ah so it was a GOOD insanity. This was more a "I bet if I were on a lot of drugs this would make sense" insanity.
Normally, I love short stories, but I don't think I could handle this book.
3 replies · active 621 weeks ago
Short story collections can be hit or miss for me. I wonder if some of these stories would have worked better as a full novel, if only so there wouldn't be so much jumping around. He'd have had the time to actually get from one point to the next.
I don't know... if he can't go from point A-B in a short story, I think a novel might be even more confusing.
Some of these stories were very short, just a couple of pages. I feel like if he gave himself more space he might be able to get from point A to point B with more explanation, instead of all of a sudden being there. Though you're right, it could just be more confusing
I think I'd enjoy this if I were watching it rather than reading it. I'm all for crazy, fever-dream visuals, but I can see how reading it could be tiresome.
1 reply · active 622 weeks ago
That's a good point. I could see this working better visually. Because reading slapstick isn't all that interesting
I'm with you on reading slapstick. I mean, I can do okay with the Stooges--sometimes I find them funny--but this just sounds boring and frustratingly stupid to me. Thanks for helping me cross one off my list!
2 replies · active 622 weeks ago
The very few times I've seen Stooges stuff I didn't think it was funny. But then again I haven't seen much and probably didn't pay enough attention the times I did. Or I just don't care for slapstick. Who knows
I think you have to be in the right mood. Ideally you're younger than 10 or have had at least three drinks.
Ugh--I don't think I could have finished this one, so good job to you. I'm with everybody else who says it might have been better rendered visually. Or if the reader were under the influence of heavy drugs...
1 reply · active 622 weeks ago
Yeah...I really only finished it cos I agreed to read it for a review. Otherwise I would have abandoned it.

Heavy drug use may have improved my feelings towards this book
hahaha this books seems way too insane for me to handle - I'd be too frustrated trying to read too much into these stories!
1 reply · active 621 weeks ago
Yeah I spent a lot of the first stories trying to figure out how we ended up where we were. Later I just knew it wasn't going to make any sense. I wish I could say I enjoyed it more when I just let things happen and didn't worry so much, but I didn't.
I... Yeah, this sounds nuts.

HOW FUCKING BORING IS IT LISTENING TO OTHER PEOPLE'S DREAMS?! It is very boring. I'm actually a fan of hearing like tiny bits from people's dreams (i.e. the funniest bits) but I happen to know a lot of people who want to tell you EVERY. DETAIL. of their dreams. I don't even want to know that much about their LIVES!

Sorry. That is a real pet peeve.
1 reply · active 621 weeks ago
RIGHT? Ugh I hate listening to people's dreams. Because it's very much full of boring stuff like 'And then we were in this house, but suddenly the house was a BOAT! But a boat with a full museum, and we could fly but only in this one room. And then..." Sorry, no, unless you were the one dreaming it, it was not interesting.
I do like slapstick, but it's only funny in reasonable quantities and in visual media (I have found). If you can't see the people falling over it's not funny! So probably not the stories for me.

I actually sort of like hearing people's dreams. I like it when their dreams have interesting symbolism. Which, like, they often do not. But sometimes they do! And I am a brilliant dream interpreter.
1 reply · active 621 weeks ago
I think these stories maay have worked filmed. And as cartoons. Maybe. But reading them didn't cut it for me. I was just confused most of the time.

I feel like the symbolism in most of my dreams is "You should probably eat less before going to bed." Or else "Oh you're reading WWZ again and are having zombie nightmares. Good job".

Maybe dreams are sort of like slapstick. It makes more sense to see them. I don't really mind dream sequences in movies or TV, but whenever I read them I zone out at least a little.
Whitney Amester's avatar

Whitney Amester · 609 weeks ago

Having read this book and enjoyed it, I found your analysis interesting. I would say that abandoning the reader was his thing. I think if after one story you hadn't caught up to that and didn't find it interesting then you weren't the intended audience. But it wasn't dream like to me. Absurd, certainly. The writer really requires one to suspend reality. So I guess this is dreamlike. I would say that endings that made sense could have strengthened some of these micro stories, but I kind of liked the crazy.
1 reply · active 609 weeks ago
Oh, it's definitely the case that this book was not for me. Had I not accepted a copy for review, I probably would have put it down after the first couple stories. But of course, to each his own.

Post a new comment

Comments by