Monday, April 25, 2011

Restlessness was in my nature

I'm finally getting around to reading Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte. You'd think I would have been shamed into reading this one sooner. I've gone on ad naseum about how much I love the Thursday Next series which begins with the book The Eyre Affair. And if you can't figure it out from the name, Jane Eyre plays a pretty large role in the book, with characters from Jane Eyre interacting with Thursday and Thursday actually jumping into Charlotte's masterpiece and becoming part of the story. While I have no doubt I missed many subtle jokes because I wasn't already familiar with the Bronte piece, it never bothered me enough to actually pick up the book. After my success with Pride and Prejudice I figured I could read some of the other literature of roughly that era.* Yet I was still apprehensive. Perhaps it's the social norms of the time, so uptight and prude, that makes me back away slowly. But I gave in and besides, it's a free copy for my Kindle, which certainly makes reading the classics easier.

I haven't finished Jane Eyre yet. Actually, I'm only 36% of the way done (yeah Kindle!) but I wanted to get my initial thoughts out there. Jane's just made it to Thornfield, but I've lost reading steam since she got there. I really liked the early chapters of Jane at Mrs. Reed's and Jane at Lowood. I had assumed I'd get a story of a kid who is good and perfect and obedient and yet is constantly berated and tormented and you feel nothing but pity for her. Thankfully that's not what Bronte provides. Jane is certainly mistreated by Mrs. Reed and her kids but she's not meek and mild, just a character to pity. When Mrs. Reed tells her kids Jane is "not worthy of notice" and that they shouldn't associate with her, Jane yells down "They are not fit to associate with me" (location 431). That's not a meek kid, that's not a kid you just pity. When she finds out she's going to leave Mrs. Reed's and go to Lowood school, Jane lets Mrs. Reed have it
I am not deceitful: if I were, I should say I loved you; but I declare I do not love you: I dislike you worst of anybody in the world except John Reed...I am glad you are no relation of mine: I will never call you aunt again as long as I live. I will never come to see you when I am grown up; and if anyone asks me how I liked you, and how you treated me, I will say the very thought of you makes me sick, and that you treated me with miserable cruelty. (location 604-611)
*A few spoilers below. I already knew most of this before reading and it hasn't ruined the story for me, but if you're worried*
I miss that spark from Jane because so far while at Thornfield it hasn't shown itself. She's been kind and good and not taken advantage of but she's just kind of bland right now. There's a crazy lady, laughing maniacally and setting people on fire, and Jane's just very eh. She's trying to figure out what's going on, but so far she's been so quiet. Plus Rochester is kind of an ass and not in the fun way Darcy was so I don't get why he's supposed to be the great love interest.

I wish there was another Helen Burns, Jane's friend from Lowood, at Thornfield. I couldn't help but think of Luna Lovegood from the Harry Potter series when I read her character. Something about the daydreaming while being punished for whatever small infraction she had committed and not getting angry at anyone. Knowing death was on her heels made her more forgiving, more relaxed and she dealt with it in a way that was years beyond her age. Perhaps I dislike the chapters after her death because I miss her. I'm holding that against subsequent chapters and should probably just get over it.
*Spoilers contained. You're safe now*

Here's to hoping things pick up in the story. So many people list this among their favorite, desert island reads, so I'm sure there is something of substance and intrigue here to latch on to.

*Wikipedia just told me Austen is part of the Regency era and Bronte isn't but I think of them as one in the same.

Title quote from location 1992

Bronte, Charlotte. Jane Eyre. Kindle edition, 2010. Originally published 1847

Comments (20)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I am finally plunging into the classics this year as well, trying to catch up on all the ones I seemed to have missed out over the years. I will be getting to Jane Eyre soon, and I look forward to it!
1 reply · active 724 weeks ago
Any classics you've read so far that you would recommend? Or recommend one avoid?
Oh my god, I'm so glad I'm not the only one who felt this way. I admit, I liked her childhood-era chapters, but by the time she gets to Thornfield she turns into some spineless, boring lady. BLAH.

And, I also don't like Mr. Rochester. He just likes to talk AT Jane, not WITH her. Jerk.

I hope that the book picks up for you and you end up enjoying it, but I really didn't like it. I feel like a freak.
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
Haha, I guess I don't have too much hope she'll quit being so spineless anytime soon. You're totally right about Rochester talking at her. So far he's confiding a bunch of stuff to her, but even he compares it to just writing something in a diary. It's not like he's asking her opinion on things, he's just talking to make himself feel better.
i don't really love this book the way some do, but i do like it...um, it's the earlier chapters that i don't like ...frankly, i may have liked the book more if there were no earlier chapters although i do so love helen burns.

in my head rochester sounds like gaston from 'disney's beautiful and the beast'...it makes the book quite hilarious...

i've also been told i should read the wide sargasso sea which is the story of rochester's wife...

have fun reading the rest of the book...
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
I've heard a few other people say they don't care for the early chapters either, so you're certainly not alone in that. I think I'll start reading Rochester with Gaston's voice. Even if I don't start enjoying the book more, at least that will amuse me
I only read part of your post (up to the bit about spoilers) because I'm one of those people that likes to go into new-to-me classics as unspoiled as possible, and (like you until recently) I haven't actually read Jane Eyre (yet). I did start it on audio a few months ago, but never made it past the first few chapters...
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
I liked the first chapters best so far, so right now I can't say keep with it. But I've heard from most people that they don't like the early stuff and that the story picks up with Jane gets to Thornfield. Good luck when you do decide to tackle this one!
I love Austen and all the Bronte sisters, but the Brontes always stand out for me because of how dark their stories tend to be. The bright cheeriness of Austen's novels can be a bit much sometimes, though I still love her. And don't worry - I group them together too, though I know I shouldn't! Persevere with Jane Eyre, it's worth it!
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
I'll stick with Jane Eyre but so far I have to say I'm preferring Lizzie and P&P to this one. I haven't actually read any of the Bronte sisters works but I'm considering Wurthering Heights, partially dependent on how this one goes.
It is weird that I don't group Austen and the Bronte's together? I feel like while their themes are similar, Austen's writing feels much older then the Bronte's.

I think the book will pick back up for you, just give it a little :)
1 reply · active 724 weeks ago
You're right to not group Austen and the Brontes together. Austen stuff is from about 30 years earlier (assuming Wikipedia has the accurate dates) and is from the Regency era while the Brontes are not. I don't know what era that count as but apparently not that one.

I plan on sticking with the book and it was all going so well at first. I'm just hoping Jane does...something. Anything.
Jane does have much more spirit in the childhood chapters, which are so vivid. Her time at Thornfield is one of loneliness and repressed anguish. She is lonely because she has no real companion -- a class issue. She is expected to efface herself. In the end I think she shows spirit, but not the rage of her childhood.
1 reply · active 724 weeks ago
She was lonely without a companion as a child, yet she was stronger and more spirited. I know an adult won't react the same way to situations as a child would, but I'd like to see some of that spark in adult Jane
I'm always ashamed to admit that I've never read Austen or any of the Bronte sisters. And I really should be, because I have this suspicion that they will be too 'girly' for me. Which, of course, is sexist. Hence, shame.

I actually do own a paperback copy of Jane Eyre, though. So you never know...
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
I should have done a Jane Eyre read along though I swear I thought I was one of the last people that hadn't read it yet. At least within the book blogging world. Pride & Prejudice was surprisingly good if you want to try out some Austen. Of course already owning a copy of Jane Eyre makes that easier to start with. I'm hoping things pick up again.
I'm definitely one that calls Jane Eyre my favorite novel of all time. It's funny because most people say the first 100 pages are the most dull! I find that once Jane really starts conversing with Rochester is when it picks up. Their conversations and banter back and forth I thought were delightful and full of energy and tension. And Jane really shows some good wit there in my opinion.

And yes, the Brontes are completely different from Austen because they are all much darker. I love the gothic tinge to the romance that Charlotte adds into Jane Eyre.
1 reply · active 724 weeks ago
I hope the banter starts soon cos so far all I've seen is Rochester talking at Jane (as Sarah above so aptly put it) and Jane being pretty subservient and not all that interesting.

I wonder if this is a reflection of what my expectations are. I was expecting (hoping) for someone closer to a Lizzie Bennet and after reading the childhood chapters, I really thought that's what I would get. And now, not so much.
So I'm trying to miss most of this post because I haven't read Jane Eyre yet (although I got an awesome graphic Penguin copy I can't wait to start) but I see that you're reading this after Jasper Ffordes (is that spelled correctly?) The Eyre Affair (which is in my cart on amazon) an I was wondering, which should I read first?

you and I seem to have very compatible book/author tastes so I love seeing what you're reading!
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
Reading Jane Eyre now, after reading The Eyre Affair, hasn't bothered me at all. I pretty much already know how Jane Eyre is going to go because of Fforde's piece, so I'm certainly missing out on some "shocking revelations". I'm not too worried about it though.

If you haven't read either and you can't wait to start Jane Eyre, I say go that way! I'm sure you'll catch a bunch of jokes in The Eyre Affair that I missed because I wasn't already intimately familiar with the story of Jane Eyre.

Post a new comment

Comments by