Tuesday, October 23, 2012

Now farming became industry

It's Tuesday so here we have another Grapes of Wrath readalong post, hosted by Laura at Devouring Texts. If you've been playing along, welcome! If not, I bet this has been boring for you. Sorry. Hope you're at least enjoying the gifs. As with each of these readalong posts, there will be spoilers.

First, things are awful in California. Of course EVERYONE has been telling the Joads that pretty much since they left, so, yeah.
Photobucket
Except to the Joads who really held onto the idea that because there were fliers there were unlimited jobs and the streets were paved with gold. I know, I'm being mean to the Joads because once they started their trek towards California it's not like they had much of a choice but to press on, even if they knew it was going to be no use. They didn't have the money to get the gas to go anywhere else. But a little acknowledgement on the Joads part would be nice.

We also lose a couple more people because the family is falling apart. But this time no one dies which is an improvement? Maybe. Casy goes to jail after a skirmish at the campsite, presumably never to be heard from again. A man tries to ensure fair wages which equals COMMUNIST so the police are called in, and they proceed to shoot a lady in the hand. Tom trips the cop and Casy knocks him unconscious. And since Tom is on parole* Casy takes the blame and is happy to be hauled away having helped the family. We the readers, on the other hand, have lost another one of the better characters. Dammit Steinbeck.

Connie also wanders off, I guess as he attempts to walk back to Oklahoma? I don't think he really got the details worked out apart from "Screw California. I'm going home." I'm sure he'll be a real success back at home after taking some classes.
Photobucket
There is a tiny ray of hope for the Joads. They end up at a government camp where the cops aren't allowed and there are toilets. Things start looking up when the Joads get running water and then I realized how low my standards have fallen for "happy times". But the family can finally hang out for awhile without being harassed and having to move every day. The men can look for work, although things aren't really that much better there. However the other families in the camp help take care of each other. Steinbeck is not subtle with his with his "we must all stick together in order to survive" thing.

Last time the family chapters were super depressing and the in between/vignette chapters had the hope (Mae & her penny candy). This time the Joad chapters have the little ray of hope and the vignettes offer up the taste of everything that's awful. There's a chapter where they talk about how farming has become an industry and a business, how the land and the crops don't matter except to the bottom line, how the people who are hired to gather the food are imported in, treated like slaves, and deported when no longer needed. How food is left rot while people are starving because it's too expensive to actually pick it. It's unfortunate how much of this is still true today. Sorry Steinbeck, your dreams of sharing and caring have not come true.

So how much more depressing can this get?
Photobucket
Only one section left to find out.

*How would they check that he's on parole in Oklahoma out in California? It's not like now where there are computers and the CA cops can check the guy out in a database. How would they find this out?

Title quote from page 316

Steinbeck, John. The Grapes of Wrath. Penguin, 1992. Originally published 1939.

Comments (16)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
You write a mean review, I must say. However, I should admit it now... I come here for the GIFs. Sublime stuff.
1 reply · active 646 weeks ago
Thank you, thank you. The gifs are typically the best part. The wording works around them.
I keep wondering the same thing about checking for parole! It's not like they had a central database of petty criminals then... did they? Or maybe they did. I'm all confused about the timing and technology and all that jazz.
1 reply · active 646 weeks ago
Right? I in general have no idea how things are done without computers but this I can't even begin to figure out...
"So how much more depressing can this get? " I'm afraid of the answer to this question.

Dystopian stories have taught me ALWAYS to distrust rumors of a land exempt from the troubles of the rest of the population. You're traveling to Alaska because that's the ONLY place in the whole world without zombies. Suuuuuure...you have fun with that.
1 reply · active 646 weeks ago
And then you have to battle yeti zombies and it's SO MUCH WORSE than you thought. You wish you could go back to normal people zombies.
DUDE, that low standards thing for happy things? Totally true. Cause the WHOLE time in the government camp, I was just like 'this is SO NICE!' but they're still living in a freaking TENT, you know?!

That parole question is a very good question! I'm thinking... the first thing they did when they arrested someone was check if they had any priors or whatever, which they presumably did with a phone and like a filing cabinet? But yeah, that's a really good point!

I HATE CONNIE SO MUCH. What a moron. But ALSO I love that JLaw gif and did look at it for about 10 minutes. So nice work!
1 reply · active 646 weeks ago
Who would the police even call to find out if Tom was on parole? I guess unless he told them "why yes, I was arrested in this city/county in Oklahoma and just recently got out of jail". I don't even know how they would begin.

Connie sucks. He's just gonna walk home to Oklahoma from California. Good plan, sir! Of course Rosasharn kinda pisses me off as well.
I completely forgot about Casy! I hope they treat him okay in jail... Who am I kidding? This is Steinbeck -- Casy will probably be beaten to death or something. *sobs*

I feel like the only reason the parole thing is a concern is because Tom is probably proud and stupid enough to brag about being in jail. So, you know, when shit goes down some other guy can just point at him and go, "He's the criminal here!" Or something.
1 reply · active 646 weeks ago
Steinbeck is totally going to do something awful to Casy. Because anyone good in this book is beat down.

I could see Tom telling everyone how he was just in jail. He does not seem able to control himself. But if he didn't do that, how would they know he was on parole. They're so concerned with that but I can't figure out how the cops would know.
The whole how would they even know he's on parole thing is driving me crazy too. I mean, did people have ID on them back then that they had to show when the cops needed to identify people? I'm pretty sure they didn't have ID with photos back then cause even my mom didn't have photo ID growing up...so it would be easy to use someone else's ID. OR if there was no such thing as having ID, couldn't you just give a fake name?? My initial fears about Tom breaking parole were silly now that I think of it...
2 replies · active 646 weeks ago
Right?? How would they know he was on parole? Maybe a lot of this was based on the honor system of people just telling you who they were and that they were on parole? I don't even know...
Ya...I was thinking the whole honor system too...but still...
WE ARE ALMOST DONE. And I feel weird about this book, because it's not like I hate reading it; I really like reading it. But it's Long. And also Sad. So my brain is like "Nooooo we don't do these thiiings."

Also I'm scared about how sad the ending's going to be.

...yup.
1 reply · active 646 weeks ago
I need something super happy after this one...

Post a new comment

Comments by