Friday, October 26, 2012

"It is hard to find a friend," I said. "It is the hardest thing in this world," he agreed.

Where to I even begin? I know! By procrastinating on this review a little longer by writing about book expectations.

This isn't the first time that I've picked up a book because other bloggers convinced me I have to. Of course I can't think of any specific examples right now, but it's happened, trust me. This time though it wasn't just a recommendation. I sort of had to read The Sisters Brothers. Not only read it but LOVE IT. Megs, Alice, and Laura all raved about it. That's so much pressure. What if I don't like it? I think I'd be shunned.

Of course there's a problem when expectations are really built up. Can anything ever stand up to such high hopes? Would the book have been better received if you weren't expecting it to be earth shattering? Of course, any recommendation is going to give you some sort of expectation for the book. And if you ignore all recommendations to avoid setting any sort of expectation before you begin, you're going to miss out.

If they (the three above and book bloggers as a whole) hadn't recommended this book, I'm sure I would have passed it by. Western, what now? No, that's cool. You keep your dusty guys and their horses and I'll just be over here. But guys, The Sisters Brothers isn't like that! Well it is, cos there are dusty guys and horses, but I loooove them. Sure, they're hired guns and there's lots of horse riding and shooting and bourbon drinking and the Gold Rush and stuff that I would expect to find in a Western. But there is so much more. The brothers, Eli and Charlie, make the story. Especially Eli, which works out nicely given he's the narrator.

Eli and Charlie are hired guns with quite the reputation. Charlie seems to really enjoy the work, but Eli's not so sure anymore. As they make the journey from Oregon City to San Francisco to kill the prospector Hermann Warm Eli decides maybe this job will be his last.

One thing about reading a book that other people have already reviewed, it means that I already have their thoughts in my head while I'm reading. At least some of their thoughts. Like Megs comment about how Eli squishes women with his love. Yeah, I kept thinking that. It may have stuck in my head because of that lion gif or because the statement is SO ACCURATE. (Both) Oh Eli, I know you mean well, but maybe back down a little bit. For a hit man he can be very sentimental, even when it comes to his sort-of-useless-but-not-at-all-I-love-him horse Tub.

I love the relationship between the brothers. It seems like it's a simple case of Charlie being the leader and Eli following, but there's more than that. There's genuine affection between the two, not only Eli for Charlie (what with all that sentimentality) but also Charlie for Eli, in his own way. His own kind of messed up way. But behind all of the affection, all of the humor is a constant feeling of sadness and loneliness. Which makes sense for a man who makes his living killing but doesn't want to anymore.

So I started this talking about expectations going into a book. There may have been some worry that I didn't like The Sisters Brothers. But I did. I did enjoy it and I can see myself reading it again. However I do think had the expectations not been built up so high I would have liked it even more. It would have surprised me with how good it really was. I hope on a second reading I can focus more on the story and the characters and the language itself.

I can't think of anything else to say so let me just throw some quotes out there, since I highlighted so much and this needs to be shared

"The creak of bed springs suffering under the weight of a restless man is as lonely a sound as I know."

"I reentered the cave to stoke the fire, curling up beside it for warmth, but I could not sleep without proper covering and instead spent the rest of the night rewriting lost arguments from my past, altering history so that I emerged victorious."

"Nodding politely, I said, 'Yes, well, it is fairly obvious that you are in love with me!"
'No,' she said, coloring. 'Not that.'
'I can see it. Hopelessly in love, powerless to guard against it. You shouldn't feel too badly about it, it has happened before.'"

"It must not have been that I loved the bookkeeper, but that I loved the idea of her loving me, and the idea of not being alone."

Hmm, a Western. Who woulda thought?

deWitt, Patrick. The Sisters Brothers. Ecco, 2011. Kindle edition.

Comments (12)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I AM SO HAPPY YOU LIKED IT

Also this review made me want to read it again. I'm sorry we were so pressurey, but I'm SO glad you read it. Because it's basically objectively great. Who's a good writer? THAT guy.
1 reply · active 645 weeks ago
I was so worried I wouldn't like it and then I'd have to go hide for awhile or something. But yes fantastic and the further into the story I got, the longer my highlighted sections were. by the end it was just paragraphs.
I'm typically wary of Westerns, but I just might cave, cos all the cool people are reading it! Oh peer pressure. Besides, a sentimental hitman? *adds to the TBR pile*
1 reply · active 645 weeks ago
Yay more blogging peer pressure.

Since I don't know the Western genre at all, I can't say if "yay you'll love this cos it's great AND a Western" or if it will be more like "oh this isn't like the other Westerns at all so you might hate it". So that comment was wholly unhelpful so I'll just say I hope you do pick it up and enjoy.
Yay, you read it and loved it! I agree about expectations sometimes affecting how much we like a book, whether positive or negative. And I think you're right about possibly liking it more because it surprised you. That's how I felt about it and that's why I've been recommending it to everyone...then again, those enthusiastic recommendations might mean they don't have the same reading experience. What a dilemma! Still, glad you enjoyed it! :)
1 reply · active 645 weeks ago
I still liked the book (OF COURSE), but I wonder how it would have been if I didn't already hear that this is the best thing. It really is a dilemma. Though I'd rather enthusiastically recommend something than stay calm
YOU WOULD NEVER BE SHUNNED. Probably.

It's interesting what you say about expectations, because EVEN THOUGH Alice and Megs had read it, I still sooort of believed that I wouldn't like it? And so the fact that I did, and that it was SO GOOD was still amazing to me! So yeah, sorry we hyped it up so much to you. But you know... Worth it!

Also, I watched True Grit and it was also SO awesome, and now I've got this whole 'hmmm, Westerns, interesting' thing going on in my brain. But maybe it's just those two. I don't know.
1 reply · active 645 weeks ago
I'm willing to give True Grit a try but I'd need more assurance that these two are not the exception to what Westerns are like. You know, assuming I like True Grit, which I haven't even tried yet. getting ahead of myself.
It was definitely the lion GIF. High schools should start using them as learning aids.

How you felt about this book is how I feel about Attachments. SO MANY EXPECTATIONS.
1 reply · active 645 weeks ago
Teachers really should incorporate GIFs into their lesson plans. Because that lion was the perfect visual for Eli and his love.

Post a new comment

Comments by