Thursday, September 12, 2013

She isn't capable of human speech...but she's excited to see you

I just read The Last Girlfriend On Earth by Simon Rich. This book is a collection of humorous short stories (on average 5-7 pages long) about dating, based on every negative stereotype about women you can think of. Not in a subversive way. In a "all women are irrational, needy, jealous, gold diggers and being in a relationship with one is akin to being in prison ISN'T THIS HILARIOUS?" type way.

I don't really know what to say beyond this. I wanted to like the book. I even found a couple of the stories funny. But then as it went on they started to get meaner and meaner and I got angrier and angrier. But I finished it because I wanted to write about it. And it was a super quick read. So how's this. Instead of me writing down a coherent review I'll just write down some quotes I highlighted and my notes I took (heart you, Kindle) with a brief description of the story.

Boy Meets Girl section
From "Unprotected"
It's the story of a condom that spends its life in his wallet.

Other than the way the condom talks ("I born in factory. They put me in wrapper. They seal me in box. Three of us in box.") this story was pretty funny. Except I spent a good amount of time going "Are you mad? You can't keep a condom in a wallet! That is going to be unusable. This is why we need better sex ed."

From "Magical Mr. Goat"
OK, this is one of the few stories I liked. A little girl conjures up an imaginary friend who goes on adventure with her. But eventually Mr. Goat wants to be more than just friends and is hurt the little girl doesn't feel the same way and just sees him as a friend. Even if I think the "friendzone" is the stupidest thing ever, this was still pretty funny.

From "Occupy Jen's Street"
"It's outrageous," he muttered through gritted teeth. "She refuses to go on a single date with me. Meanwhile, the fat cats on Wall Street just sit there, getting richer and richer."
I was confused.
"What do the fat cats have to do with Jen?"
"It's all connected," he said vaguely.

This was around the point I started to get worried about this book. This story is still pretty funny, but in a bit of a creepy way. It's about how this guy who is GREAT at leading protests decides to lead a full-scale protest outside of Jen's apartment until she agrees to go on a date with him. Overall the story is pretty funny, although you sorta just go with the idea that the woman in this story (and the women in ALL the stories) aren't actual characters. They're demonized or idolized. Cos then you get lines like this from the same story

"Ninety-nine percent of men are in love with the top one percent of women. And yet they often refuse to date us. It's a complete injustice."

...ugh

Boy Gets Girl section

I pretty much hated every story in this section and got angrier and angrier as I read on.

From "Scared Straight"
"His name is Dan Greenbaum. And he's been in a long-term relationship with his girlfriend, Sarah, for seven years."
For the first time all day, Kyle felt his shoulders tensing up. He'd never actually met a real inmate before.

My note:
"ahaha yes, I get it. Relationships are a prison. And these boys are being shown what horrors could be in their future if they don't change their ways, a la Scared Straight. HILARIOUS. We're breaking some new ground now."

From "Center of the Universe"
The story is about God having a needy girlfriend that gets annoyed with him for not showering her with enough attention cos he's busy making the world.

My note:
"ahaha, look at women being so demanding. Even God is whipped by them. If you try to have a relationship with them they will cut off your nuts. Why, this is even more hilarious than the last story"

From "Girlfriend Repair Shop"
His girlfriend would be diagnosed with some mental problem: depression, possibly, or something menstruation-related"


My note, immediately after that quote:
This fucking guy

This story is about a guy that goes to couples counseling with his girlfriend, but DON'T WORRY, he's fine. See all women are actually robots and she's not unhappy. She's just malfunctioning slightly. Tighten a couple screws and she'll forget all about her feelings. Hmm women as robots so they'll be perfect wives/girlfriends. Well isn't that just a TOTALLY ORIGINAL IDEA.

From "The Adventure of the Spotted Tie"
Sherlock Holmes has a gold digging girlfriend that's cheating on him (AS WOMEN DO) and even though he's a genius he can't see that she's obviously just using him for his money. This fucking guy.

From "The Last Girlfriend on Earth"
A disease wipes out all women on the planet except this one woman. Now all these guys want to hang out with her and her boyfriend is jealous because they all want to sleep with her and she is surprised these guys don't want to just hang out with her. Then it turns out there's a second girl and the first girl gets super catty and jealous LIKE WOMEN DO.

OK, at this point I pretty much just started writing "This fucking guy" after every story. So maybe these quotes thing won't work anymore. But I'm sure you get the point.

There's a final section called Boy Loses Girl with stories like the one about the secret agent that who uses the invisibility serum he's supposed to be using to track and take out a terrorist to spy on his ex girlfriend and fun stuff like that. There was one other story I liked called "Man Seeking Woman" that is funny and is also something like 50 words long. But it was too little, too late.

I don't think all the stories should have nice to women or couldn't play off stereotypes (offensive and not) for the plot. But all of them? They all had to? Just...no.

Title quote from page 52, location 488

Rich, Simon. The Last Girlfriend On Earth and Other Love Stories. Regan Arthur Books, 2012. Kindle edition.

Comments (23)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
But the "It's a complete injustice" is him making fun of himself, right?

Otherwise -- DAMNIT, MEN.

I don't think it's any secret that I find men overall kind of boring and (yeah, I'll say it) untrustworthy and I don't want to be in a relationship with one. But that doesn't mean I ACTUALLY THINK every guy in a relationship will be a dick and cheat on you or do some other piece of shit move. Because I've met actual, human men. And it bothers me that this guy seems to not actually have met any women outside of, I dunno, Las Vegas? All the people there are shitty, right?

I had a conversation with a friend a while back about why men do these serial killery/rapey things primarily against young women, and he said that part of it might be that women are seen as the gatekeepers, and to hold a tremendous amount of power (pretty much exclusively re: sex). Whenever I see embittered thought collections like the above book, I see a guy who's scared of women.

...it's 8 AM. I might not be at my most clear-thinking. But I THINK that's what I wanted to say.
6 replies · active 605 weeks ago
There were times when he was poking fun at men, but it was usually the case of "look how pathetic men are because of what women do to them!" The humor (I guess) in the Holmes story was the fact that Holmes is a genius but he can't see that his girlfriend is just using him. Look how pathetic he is.

I think it's totally the gatekeeper thing. And there was probably a thing in Cracked about women and why men are assholes and it said the whole idea of the gatekeeper thing and the idea that men are taught in pretty much every form of pop culture that a guy is "owed" a woman. The hero gets the girl, we're all heroes in our own stories, therefore when a girl rejects a guy it's not just him getting dumped. It's someone reneging on a (totally unspoken, just in his head) contract.
And then we get Nice Guy Syndrome, which is usually hilariously along the lines of "Why won't she go out with me? It's because I'm a nice guy. Fuck her."
This entire book is filled with "Nice Guys"
Oh fuck, the 'nice guy'. 'Im too nice to women, that's why they won't have sex with me.' Or... Maybe they know you're only hanging around them TO have sex with them and she doesn't like you like that but she's the bitch because she actually wants to be your friend?

'Nice guys' can go fuck themselves. Literally.
"I'm only hanging out with this woman in the hopes she'll have sex with me, even though she's made it clear she only likes me as a friend. God, I'm such a nice guy, she's such a bitch for not screwing me"
ARGHH. We have clearly all met "the nice guy."
Thanks for saving me the time of reading this myself. Funny? Good. Misogynistic? No thanks.
1 reply · active 605 weeks ago
Glad I could help. cos yeah...

At first I was like 'OK so the stories are kind of sexist but they aren't especially hateful to women." And then I got to the Boy Gets Girl part and then I was like "Ohh nooope! Everyone one of these stories would find a welcome home on a misandry forum"
You know... I read this book ages ago, and reading this reminded me how much a lot of the stories annoyed me with how they portrayed women... but in the meantime, I completely forgot about all of that stuff and could just remembered the stories that I liked, which meant that when I got around to posting about it on my blog I ended up being overly positive about it. In fact, I'm going to link to your post as you said all the stuff that I forgot to say. (I still think that I have a more positive view of the book than you do, and I'm hoping that this was just an unfortunate coincidence, rather than showing the author's world view... it does reflect general depictions of women in general, so mabye the problem is more with society and less with the book? Yeah, I'm way too generous.)

I wonder if a similar book written from a female perspective would have as many stereotypical and unfair portrayals of men? I don't really think that would be a problem, as despite what certain groups say men are not and have never really been oppressed by women, I'm just wondering... hmm.
2 replies · active 605 weeks ago
It's like your brain was trying to protect itself and it blocked out all of the horrible parts. cos there were a couple funny parts. It was just mostly horrible things.

I think a woman COULD have written a book like this that had many unfair portrayals of men. I also think this book could have been written by a man but without the "women are terrible" stereotypes.
Yeah, probably! I think my brain does that a lot. Thinking about it, the stories that I can remember liking all came from the first bit of the book, which should really have helped me to remember when I was writing about it!

I would like to read a book with the same premise but without the same stereotypes in!
The fact that this book exists makes me want to punch everyone in the face. It sounds like the WORST. Like, I would have snapped my kindle in half reading it, it seems! GOD, PEOPLE.

In other thoughts, condoms in wallets are baaaaad news.
4 replies · active 605 weeks ago
I'm pretty sure I was mumbling to myself while I was on the subway while reading this. And angry laughing to myself. I'm pretty much that crazy person on the subway when I'm reading something I'm really...I don't want to say into but something that pulls me in, even if it's in a bad way.

Right? And I mean, at one point in the story (which I assume you don't care if I tell you the ending to) this lady tells him he can't use that cos it's expired, but don't worry cos she has some. Which yes it's expired but also IT'S BEEN IN HIS WALLET AND PROB DRIED OUT AND HAS CRACKS AND DON'T USE THAT! There needs to be a public service announcement
God, I can't believe you spoiled that story for me, Alley. Hahahaha, but yes, and also THE FRICTION! Friction is not good! Don't keep those there!
I actually had no idea it was bad to keep a condom in your wallet. GOOD thing I'm married and not in charge of condom storage. AMIRITE? (Because women are silly and should never be trusted with important contraceptives. Oh God...look where I've ended up in this comment.)
SEE this is why we need better sex ed. People should know this! It's important stuff
I heard about this from one other person who seriously LOVED it. And I'm really surprised now, because she's a super-feminist. I can't fathom how all that stuff made it under her radar or at least didn't garner a MENTION while she was raving about it. You've saved me, and I am in your debt.
1 reply · active 605 weeks ago
I want to know why your super-feminist friend liked it cos really, while I was reading it I kept thinking "Am I missing something? Maybe I'm taking this way too seriously". Which is sort of why I wanted to include quotes cos LOOK I'M NOT MAKING THIS UP
BLEEUUUUCCHHHHH.
1 reply · active 605 weeks ago
Ahahahahahaha. Yes. Exactly

Post a new comment

Comments by