Monday, September 9, 2013

Everyone needs to think they have secrets

The other day tweet from Laura about how I was going to make sure I finished Tell The Wolves I'm Home because of all the sads. And then on my way home that night the train in front of me hit...something* and we were delayed. Which mean I had loads of time to do nothing but read and my phone was almost dead so I couldn't keep screwing around on there. And that's how I ended up crying on the train and DAMMIT, IT WASN'T SUPPOSED TO HAPPEN THAT WAY.


I would like to start this review by directing you over to Megs' review because it says everything I want to say only better, and also is the main reason I picked up this book in the first place. Or at least the reason I added it to my TBR. Finding it on sale at Costco is why it got picked up.**

I know I already told you about how this book hits you in the feels, but it's in a good way. And that's not all there is to it. June is a misunderstood teen. I know what you're thinking, aren't they all? But June is. She's awkward and a loner, she used to be close with her sister but at some point they've grown apart. she wishes she lived in another time, specifically Renaissance time. She likes to wander into the woods behind the school, wear the special boots her uncle gave her and a Renaissance dress that's far too small and pretend she's actually a Renaissance maiden. So yeah, she doesn't have too many friends. But she has her Uncle Finn, so she's good. He understands her, lets her be who she is, and is always there for her. Until he isn't.

Don't worry, that isn't a spoiler. It's the set up. Because when Finn is no longer there for June she finds someone else she'd never before met who misses Finn as much as she does.

I know Megs did this too but it is really hard to talk about this book without some mild spoilers. They're spoilers that I don't think will mess up the book AT ALL if you haven't read it yet but in case you want to go in without knowing anything you should prob stop now. And then go read the book right now because it's really good. Really, really good.

*Really minor spoilers that you're probably safe to read but fair warning*
June is torn by this stranger Toby turning up, because here is someone that knows all about a Finn she never knew. But it also means that she wasn't everything to Finn like Finn was to her. There were many times I wanted to yell at June for being so mean, but then again her angry, her defensiveness, her frustration, is understandable. Learning that she isn't the only one who misses Finn so much is both a blessing and a curse.

The story isn't just about June and Toby. It's also June's family and their relationships. Particularly June and Greta, her great-at-everything older sister. And then there's June's mother and her relationship both with June and with her brother Finn. Everyone in the family is dealing with loss in different ways. And different losses.

This book made me angry at the '80s. I guess it's hard to blame them. AIDS was a new disease and no one really knew much about it or how it was spread but just that if you got it, it wasn't good. And also you probably deserved what you got because you brought it on yourself because did I mention people are terrible? Because they can be. Especially when they're scared and confused. I have vague memories of a Sesame Street telling you all the ways you couldn't catch AIDS, like giving someone a hug.

There's so much more I want to say but to do that will get into larger spoilers that I don't think would mess up the story if you already knew them but then again, who knows they might. So I'll stop talking about the plot.

I already told you about the sads. I mean, it's a book about AIDS and death so of course it's sad but even these sads aren't the focus. It's about more than that. I wasn't angry at the book for making me cry. I was angry at the book for making me cry on the train, but that was really the fault with the book being so good that even though I knew the sads would be coming I had to read in, public be damned.

I didn't realize this was YA while I was reading it. I really don't think I can pick out YA if asked to. It has a teenage protagonist but that's about it. Maybe that's enough? I guess I don't know enough about the genre, but yeah, if you're avoiding this one because you don't read YA you're doing yourself a disservice. It's also a quick read. Because you can't put it down. Even if you're now crying on the train.

*They originally thought it was a someone, which is happening with surprising frequency, but I'm guessing since we were only stuck for around 30 min that it was a something. They didn't say.
**And apparently this is specifically a "for Costco" copy of the book. It even has a "Dear Costco Readers" thing from the author at the beginning.

Title quote from page 354

Brunt, Carol Rifka. Tell The Wolves I'm Home. Dial Press Trade Paperback, 2012.

Comments (31)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Books that make you cry in public are THE WORST. Except that sometimes they are the best, like this one, apparently.

I should probably read this. Especially because it has a teapot on the cover and I am drinking a cup of tea right now. If that isn't fate, I don't know what is.
1 reply · active 602 weeks ago
Ugh FINE I'll read it. Damn you people.
1 reply · active 602 weeks ago
I have been so traumatised (in the best way) by this book that just reading your review has given me a lump in my throat because oh my god everything about it. I can't believe you still finished this in public after my totally sensible warning! Except that I can because I totally get the not being able to put it down thing.

I'm planning to review this this week ('planning to' cause, you know, stuff) so I won't bore you with all my thinks (YET) but I'm so feeling your mad at the eighties thing, PLUS (and this is how I was going to start my review) I'm kind of bowled over by the way that fiction has made me have all the ampathy ever for victims of AIDS in spite of me never knowing anyone who has had it ever. It's kind of best (the thing that books and films have done, not AIDS. Obviously.)
2 replies · active 602 weeks ago
This one is high on my want list, and I love books that make me cry in public. That's POWER!
1 reply · active 602 weeks ago
I love this book! I found it not long after an old friend died suddenly, and I was dealing with just how confusing death can be: how someone can just be there one day and not the next. And it was exactly the book I had to read at that time.

I'm not sure whether I'd class it as a YA book - over here (UK) it has been filed in the general fiction section of bookshops and libraries. But at the same time, I think teenagers would appreciate it too - a book for all ages.
1 reply · active 602 weeks ago
Ooh, I wrote my review of this last weekend but it's not scheduled to post until Thursday--we're ALL reading this book, aren't we?

It's not actually a YA novel. It just features a first person 14 year old protagonist, which almost always turns out to be a YA thing. Definitely could be a YA crossover, though.

I really, really liked this book but ended up admiring it more than loving it. Many bits of it reminded me of living through the AIDS scare of the 1980s, but to be honest, this book is supposed to be set in 1987 and we knew by then that things like sharing chapstick wouldn't give you AIDS, or as we now say,HIV. So little things like that in the book rang true for me in terms of the scare in the early 1980s, but not by 1987, if that makes sense.
1 reply · active 602 weeks ago
My first memory of someone mentioning AIDS was my mum saying how upsetting she found Freddie Mercury's death, not only because he died (obvs) but because his last few years were spent hiding away from paparazzi and having people define him by his illness and completely forgetting what a fascinating man and musician he was.

And if you want a book that will make you mad at people regarding outdated views on AIDS read April Fool's Day by Bryce Courtenay. It's about the author's son who was hemophiliac and contracted AIDS through a blood transfusion and was ostracised by everyone except his family and girlfriend. It is the most upsetting book I think I've ever read, and it made me so angry at people.

I'm mainly telling you all this since I haven't yet read this (although I want to SO BAD) and have nothing to really add to the conversation.
2 replies · active 601 weeks ago
Don't feel too bad. I've cried in public while reading more times then I am willing to admit. And it always seems to catch me by surprise with titles that I didn't realize how invested I was. This has been on my list for awhile, but I'll make sure to read it in the saftey of my room next to some tissues.
1 reply · active 602 weeks ago
This book club that I'm sort of in (AKA have attended once) was reading this last month and I was all not wanting to spend money on a book that I had never heard of and that the copy on the back of the book didn't actually make me want to read but now I'm kind of regretting it. Sometimes sort-of-spoilers are just necessary.
1 reply · active 602 weeks ago
First of all, you're the sweetest for linking to my post and making it sound as though it was anything more than blubbering and a GIF of a cat swatting a dog.

SECOND, I laughed a lot when I saw your e-mail the other day. It was kind of an evil laugh. A Disney villain laugh.

THIRD, I'm pretty impressed that you finished the saddest book ever on a train that was stopped because there may or may not have been a corpse on the tracks. That's poetic, really.
1 reply · active 602 weeks ago
It wasn't marketed as a YA novel but I have no idea what's supposed to distinguish it from one. Isn't it wonderful? I read it when it came out and absolutely loved it, and I expected it to be a HUGE BIG DEAL and it wasn't at all. It's such a shame! The book is wonderful and it has a wonderful title and the painting stays changed at the end because they can't tell the mother's additions apart from what Finn actually drew---aaaa. I am feeling feelings right now because of this book.
1 reply · active 602 weeks ago
Ah man, everyone's reviews make me want to read this, but when I read the blurb on the book, I'm not inclined to pick it up/purchase it. What's up with that? Obviously I trust you guys way more than some blurb, but how many other people are passing this book up I wonder? Anyway, here's hoping Canadian costco has this book!
1 reply · active 602 weeks ago
This book was so amazing and so sobby and I loved it's face right off. I need to own it.
1 reply · active 601 weeks ago
I've been meaning to read this but wasn't sure if the topic would be too weepy. Your recommendation definitely inspires me to pick it up.
1 reply · active 599 weeks ago

Post a new comment

Comments by