Monday, March 28, 2016

Some of the best ideas in history - nearly all of them, in fact - sounded crazy at first

When to Rob a Bank...and 131 More Warped Suggestions and Well-Intentioned Rants. Collection of blog posts that haha, you could have just read for free. Sucker!

It was fine. It was entertaining, as Freakonomics tends to be. They were upfront about the fact that you totally could have just read the blog posts for free on their site, so at least I didn't feel blindsided by that. They felt a little bad for it but justified by it by comparing it to bottled water.
So in the tradition of Poland Spring, Evian, and other hydro-geniuses, we've decided to bottle something that was freely available and charge you money for it.
They do point out they curated which posts they included to pick the best ones, arranged them in an order that made sense and did some editing. So not exactly what's on the blog. And honestly, while I listen to the podcast, I don't really read the blog so a good amount of the stuff here was new to me.

Some of the ideas are clever or at least interesting. There's a post titled "Planned Parenthood Gets Freaky"talks about a Philly Planned Parenthood strategy called "Pledge-a-Picket". This PP got a lot of protesters so the idea was people would pledge a certain amount per protester (minimum ten cents) that showed up. The PP would count and record the number and place a sign in full view of the protesters that let them know exactly how them showing up is benefitting the Planned Parenthood.

There's another post about using a different bus stop than normal, which in and of itself doesn't sound that interesting, but it does have the line
Having just gotten off the subway, the Point A passengers are already broken in spirit and can't muster the energy to improve their commute
which quite accurately describes public transportation commuting. I understand why those people don't want to walk another block over.

Because these are just blog posts, each chapter is short (which is how they can shove 131 of them in here) which can be a good thing if you just want to jump in and read a couple quickly. But I also found myself wishing they'd take some of these blog posts and expand them into longer chapters. I would really want them to dig into a topic when all of a sudden, the post is done and we're onto a different topic.

Gif rating:
Title quote from page 5

Dubner, Stephen and Steven Levitt. When to Rob a Bank...and 131 More Warped Suggestions and Well-Intentioned Rants. William Morrow, 2015.

Comments (4)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
That Planned Parenthood thing is genius. Pledging for picketers! Amazing.
1 reply · active 467 weeks ago
Right?? How great is that? and as long as there are people pledging, it's win-win for Planned Parenthood. They either get donations or they get rid of the picketers
I love that PP thing!

I always have that moment of "why buy the book when you can read the blog for free" when I see blog books on sale. That said, I think a book like this works really well as a gift, because I have so many friends who I say "you should listen to X podcast or read Y book" and never do, and this would be a good way of introducing it to them.
1 reply · active 466 weeks ago
This would be a good way and they do a LITTLE bit beyond just reposting the blogs. They put them into categories, they add some intro to the sections. Not a huge amount but the fact that they were upfront about it made me overall happier with the result. And I mean, that PP thing.

Post a new comment

Comments by