Wednesday, July 23, 2014

There’s something disturbing about recalling a warm memory and feeling utterly cold


I need to write a post about a book. Except I don’t have internet at the moment* and can’t remember the next book I’m supposed to review because I am terrible at staying on top of these things. Go me.

Alright, I haven’t figured out the internet but I did manage to figure out which was the last book I read. Because I pulled it up on my phone. It’s really sad how dependent on the interwebs I am. Anyway.

I finally read Gone Girl. I’m not really sure what I should say about it, considering most everyone has already read this one and knows the twist and blah blah blah. But not knowing what to say has never stopped me from talking before so why should it make a difference now?

By now I’m sure you’ve heard the basics of the story. Nick and Amy had a seemingly perfect marriage but when Amy goes missing things start to fall apart with that facade. Is Nick responsible for Amy’s disappearance? Is there something else going on?

Obviously as I mentioned above, and as you probably already know, there’s a twist. Had I not known there was a twist I’m sure things would have come as more of a surprise. As it was I was waiting for something to happen and when it did, I can’t say I predicted it exactly but at the same point I wasn’t really surprised by it. Which was fine. Knowing it didn’t really ruin anything for me. I’m not sure what my reaction would have been had I not known something was coming.

I also heard about how everyone haaaaaaaaaated all of the characters. And they are not wrong. Everyone is just the worst. That again didn't really bother me. I didn’t like the characters. I don’t want to spend any time with them, but that doesn’t mean I don’t want to read about them. I think knowing this already meant I wasn’t expecting to like them, therefore wasn’t disappointed when they turned out to be terrible, and could just focus on the story instead of being pissed at these dipshits.

For the most part I liked the book. It was definitely a page-turner, so I’d say it was doing its job. And there were moments where the writing was great or Flynn made some great points. (I love the "cool girl" rant.) I wanted to see what was going to happen, what was really going on, what the hell does that comment/clue/look mean, etc. Everything a good thriller should do. The ending though…I was not crazy about the ending. Which I suppose bodes well for the movie given Flynn’s changing it for the movie. Maybe if I had read it before all the hype I would have liked it better. Overall it was a good thriller that probably doesn’t deserve all of the praise or hatred that’s been heaped on it.

Gif rating

*"At the moment" meaning at the time of writing. Which was actually quite a few days ago at this point.

Title quote from somewhere, except I wrote this post while on vacation and the book was back at home, so I searched for quotes from the book and I like this one, but Goodreads doesn't list what page the quote is from (because everyone has different versions anyway) so yeah. I'm doing so well right now.

Flynn, Gillian. Gone Girl. Crown Publishing, 2012. 

Comments (16)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
BUT don't you feel like they're just suited for each other? You wouldn't want those people foisted on someone else.
1 reply · active 560 weeks ago
Yes, this is true. But can't they just both be miserable alone?
She's changing the ending for the movie!? That makes me so happy because I LOVED this book until the ending. I was incredibly unhappy with it.
Oddly, I didn't HATE Nick. He seemed like a tool, that was for sure, but... well I guess for the sake of not posting spoilers, I'll stop here.
I also loved the "cool girl" rant. I was much more surprised about the twist. I knew there was one but I assumed it was going to be more along the lines of a shocker as to who "did it". I've been wanting to talk about this book for a while - thanks for posting!
1 reply · active 560 weeks ago
I didn't hate Nick, certainly not like Amy. He just seemed like an asshole but he wasn't really hurting anyone. OK, well he was hurting Amy but she's terrible.

I did very much enjoy the "cool girl" rant. She made a good point about people just trying to pretend they are the "cool girl" whatever that might mean for the guy.

I can't wait for hte movie and see what she does with the new ending.
I think you did fine with this review! You know I like you best when you're all, um, *thinks of a nice way to put this* honest? Haha stream of consciousness ftw.

ANYWAY. I know I really liked this while I was reading it (apart from knowing there was a twist, obvs) but the second I finished it, I was kind of just like eh. All I have to say about the movie is that Ben Affleck is probably perfect to play nick because they both annoy me SO MUCH.
1 reply · active 560 weeks ago
Awww thank ya.

I think I'm the same way about it. I liked it a lot more while I was reading it. I don't dislike it now that it's done but I'm more eh about it.

I am very much looking forward to the movie and yes, I agree that Ben Affleck is probably the perfect Nick. Which, poor Affleck.
I literally (and I'm actually using the word correctly for once!) just finished Gone Girl. Really, like ten minutes ago, and I have to say I FEEL this post. Of course being online and reading about books I knew about the twist and i think that kind of ruined the entire book for me. I know i would have enjoyed it more if I wasn't waiting for it.
Your review seriously captured all my thoughts, it's probably a good thing i'm so behind that my gone girl one won't get posted for like two months :/
1 reply · active 560 weeks ago
I think I may have enjoyed the book more if I didn't know a twist was coming BUT I still enjoyed. So good job on Flynn for not making the book ALL twist.

I am SUUUUPER behind on all of my other reviews. I'm lucky I got this one done.
I didn't hate the ending, but I'm still interested to see what Gillian Flynn came up with for the alternate movie ending. Something very creepy, I hope!
1 reply · active 560 weeks ago
I know that it isn't how the world works but I REALLY wanted Amy to be punished more. Just, UGH, how can she get so away with it.

I do hope she doesn't change it to...well I don't know that a happy ending is really possible without just writing a new movie. But I do look forward to something new
I loved this book. The ending was a bit of a bummer, but I love how nuts the main characters are. I love David Fincher so I'm very excited he is directing the movie. I'm reading Sharp Objects now by Gillian Flynn so hopefully it'll be good too.
1 reply · active 560 weeks ago
The main characters are so crazy. And when you think you hav a handle on how nuts they are they out crazy your assumptions.

I'll probably get to more Flynn at some point. Not right away, but eventually.
While I read this one already, I have yet to read Dark Places (did you read that one yet?)
Your review was spot-on. The characters are despicable, but you're dragged along for the ride because it is suspenseful and in the end you're like "yep, you two totally deserve each other".
Are you still on your honeymoon? Leave the internet at once and enjoy the week off :)
1 reply · active 560 weeks ago
This is the only Flynn I've read so far. I'll probably try her other stuff eventually. Just not right away.

I was on my honeymoon when this posted BUT I had it all scheduled cos I was on a boat completely without internet access. And it was awesome. Both the honeymoon and being without internet for a period of time.
I will never read this book, and I do know the spoiler, and I will probably see the film without getting fussed about missing out on the book.

But I think the main question here is this: why ON EARTH are you blogging about Gone Girl whilst you're on vacation? and not just any old vacation, but a honeymoon? Even if you did write some of it ahead of time?
1 reply · active 560 weeks ago
Yeah, I wouldn't think the book would be your thing. It was good but not a "OMG I know this isn't your usual genre but you HAAAAVE to try it" type thing.

DON'T WORRY, I wrote this ahead of time. Actually all my stuff about not having internet was when I was at my friend's wedding over July 4th weekend. And then I just had this post sitting there waiting to go.

Post a new comment

Comments by