Monday, November 11, 2013

Coraline discovered the door a little while after they moved into the house

My October reading was pretty slim on creepy stories. I thought I should fix that and people have been saying lots of good things about Coraline AND it's a children's story so it's on the short side so it seemed like a good choice. Bookish internet, you have such good taste.

I know I've called it a children's story, but it is a seriously creepy story. Coraline recently moved with her parents to a new home in a once mansion/now apartment building. There are no other children around and only so much entertainment she can get from the elderly (and slightly crazy) neighbors. Her parents work from home but they both work from home and are too busy to play with her. One day she finds a door in the drawing room, but when her mother opens it it just leads to a brick wall. Until one day Coraline opens the door herself and there's a hallway that leads to a replica of her family's apartment. It's complete with Other Mother, a woman who seems to be just like Coraline's mother except she has big black buttons instead of eyes. She and other father want Coraline to say with them.

Things in the Other Flat seem nice at first. I mean, except for the fact that everyone has buttons instead of eyes. But things moved from unsettling to creepy to sinister pretty quickly. Ghosts and monsters and of course Other Mother wants Coraline to stay with her. Forever.

It's a modern fairy tale. In a way. There are no princesses but there are quests to complete and monsters to overcome. And Coraline is just the right heroine. She's a child, but not a precocious one. She seems like a real child. She's brave and she's scared. She wants to go exploring. There's a quote early on that sums up Coraline nicely
There was also a well. On the first day Coraline's family moved in, Miss Spink and Miss Forcible made a point of telling Coraline how dangerous the well was, and they warned her to be sure she kept away from it. So Coraline set off to explore for it, so that she knew where it was, to keep away from it properly.

I haven't (yet) seen the movie version of this, but just from reading it I'm pretty sure they picked the perfect medium. This feels like it was made for stop-motion animation, especially done by the same team that did Nightmare Before Christmas. Even when it's about cheerful things stop motion has an eerie quality to it.

This was the perfect Halloween read and it was short enough to finish in about an hour. I've had mixed feelings about Gaiman. American Gods was not my thing but I loved Good Omens. So I went into Coraline unsure of what I'd be getting. I knew people had very good things to say about it. But so far the only Gaiman work I liked involved having Terry Pratchett at the wheel as well. After this book I trust Gaiman if a) he's writing with someone else or b) if he's writing a children's story.

In the names post I mentioned I liked the name Coraline so much because it's like Caroline except twisted. It's a simple change that makes the name so fresh. And guess what? Gaiman came up with the name because he mistyped Caroline, and what a lovely mistake.

Title quote from page 3

Gaiman, Neil. Coraline. Harper Perennial, 2002.

Comments (13)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Yeah. This is one of his good ones. For it is a book for children, and he excels at those. I liked the movie, but I saw it before I read the book SO NOW I CAN'T KNOW WHAT I REALLY THINK OF EITHER.
3 replies · active 597 weeks ago
Well you can know what you think of the movie right? Cos you saw that first. That opinion is untainted by the book. I really want to see the movie. The lady at the Strand was telling me about the movie and how long it took to animate scenes that I didn't know were things cos I hadn't read the book yet. She was pretty excited.
BUT THE MOVIE WAS INFORMED BY THE BOOK AND I DIDN'T READ THE BOOK FIRST WHICH THEY MIGHT'VE ASSUMED I'D DONE I DON'T KNOW

This feels very chicken/egg.
Hahaha. I sort of thought of the movie while reading the book. I mean I haven't seen the movie yet but I saw the commercials and it looks like a movie I WOULD have seen. Except I'm lazy and prob couldn't get anyone else that wanted to see it.
WEIRD THINGS WITH EYES FREAK ME OUT. I haven't read this but I watched them movie in French on a flight to France (to practice) a few years back and just the memory makes me shudder. The super-creepiness was probably due a little bit to the fact that I didn't actually understand all of it, but mostly because EYE BUTTONS WTF. But yeah. I intend to one day read this. Maybe. (Oh and I like the thing about the name, I've never heard that before.)
1 reply · active 597 weeks ago
This isn't quite the same AT ALL but it makes me think of it so I'm gonna bring it up anyway. I watched Corpse Bride in Italian in Italy. I did it in part to brush up and also cos that was the language it was offered in. Though it had English subtitles. I think. Or maybe it was the other way.

Anyway, yeah button eyes. SUPER CREEPY. Actually, there are a few drawings in the book and they are all super creepy. Which is sort of the extra push that got me to read this.
My main memory of the movie was how damn cool the 3D was. It was one of the first movies I saw in 3D, though, so maybe it was just the glow of novelty. The movie's not as good as the book. There is this whole other kid character to hang out with Coraline, which I get why they would have that in a movie, but one of the things I loved about Coraline as a book was how solitary she was. Just her and a cat to take care of matters.
1 reply · active 597 weeks ago
Hmmm yeah I sort of liked the idea that Coraline was on her own (mostly, though as you point out, she had the cat) through this. Damn you movies and your need for sidekicks.
I have still yet to read any Gaiman (I know!) but it feels like EVERYONE read Coraline this halloweenish time and LOVED it so... Perhaps that is where I'll start. It sounds like just the right amount of creepy to me.
3 replies · active 596 weeks ago
Reeeeeeeeeaaaaad it. it's such a quick read. Big font, big margins, pictures. but so creepy. I feel like kid me would have loved it, even though adult me is like "This seems way too creepy for kids." Which is dumb. This is totally the right amount of creepy and perilous for kids.
SO RIGHT about it being like Roald Dahl. Cos I loooooooooooved Dahl as a kid. And when I look at his stuff now I'm like "wow, that is a lot darker than I remember". But then again all the dark stuff was my fav. So really, kids are way tougher/able to filter out the really terrible stuff better than we think
Great post !

Post a new comment

Comments by